https://doi.org/10.1177/0896920518790651
Critical Sociology
1–14
© The Author(s) 2018
Article reuse guidelines:
sagepub.com/journals-permissions
DOI: 10.1177/0896920518790651
journals.sagepub.com/home/crs
The Democratization of Global
Governance through Civil Society
Actors and the Challenge from
Political Equality
Eva Erman
Stockholm University, Sweden
Abstract
In the theoretical literature on global democracy, the influential transmission belt model depicts
transnational civil society as a transmission belt between the public space and the empowered
space (decision-making loci), assuming that civil society actors contribute to the democratization
of global governance by transmitting peoples’ preferences from the public space to the empowered
space through involvement in the political decision-making. In this article, two claims are made.
First, I argue that the transmission belt model fails because insofar as civil society has formalized
influence in the decision-making, it is illegitimate, and insofar as it has informal influence, it
is legitimate, but civil society’s special status as transmitter is dissolved. Second, I argue that
civil society is better understood as a transmission belt, not between the public space and the
empowered space, but between the private space (lifeworld) and the public space. It is here that
civil society is essential for democracy, with its unique capacity to stay attuned to concerns in the
lifeworld and to communicate those in a publically accessible form.
Keywords
political theory, democratic theory, civil society, global governance, democratization,
transmission belt, political equality
Introduction
Understood in the abstract, the ideal of democracy, ‘the rule by the people’, contains a form of
political rule or organization where the members have an equal say in the decision-making.
Although there are numerous different models of democracy, most of them assume that civil soci-
ety plays a vital role for democracy by displaying the interests, preferences and will of the people
and by promoting a political culture of ‘democratic’ norms in the society. There is of course also a
myriad of theories about what civil society consists of, but on a broad outlook, the term ‘civil
Corresponding author:
Eva Erman, Department of Political Science, Stockholm University, 106 91 Stockholm, Sweden.
Email: eva.erman@statsvet.su.se
0 0 10.1177/0896920518790651Critical SociologyErman
research-article 2018
Article