The Ecology of Teachers’ Experiences with Violence and Lack of
Administrative Support
Susan D. McMahon, Samantha Reaves, Elizabeth A. McConnell, Eric Peist, Linda Ruiz, and the APA Task Force
on Classroom Violence Directed Against Teachers
Highlights
• Teacher-directed violence is a significant problem in schools.
• Lack of support from administrators was one of teachers’ most upsetting experiences.
• An ecological framework was used to examine lack of administrative support across multiple levels.
• Implications for research, practice, and policy are provided to improve administrative support.
© Society for Community Research and Action 2017
Abstract Teacher-directed violence is a common, yet
understudied, phenomenon. Perpetrators of violence
against teachers include not just students, but also
administrators, parents, and colleagues. Administrators are
key stakeholders when it comes to shaping school climate
and safety that can reduce or increase the negative impact
of violence against teachers. In this study, 237 teachers’
qualitative responses from a larger sample of 2,431
anonymous, online survey responses were examined to
better understand their experiences with incidents of
violence and how administrators played a role in these
experiences. Results reveal that lack of administrator
support negatively impacts teachers at multiple levels,
including teachers’ feelings (individual); challenges
associated with addressing issues related to students,
parents, and other perpetrators (interpersonal); and school
systems and policies (organizational). This study
highlights the importance of administrative support and
illustrates how administrators’ actions and inactions can
have ripple effects at each level of the school microcosm.
Implications for research, practice, and policy are
discussed.
Keywords Teacher victimization
Administrators
Support
School climate
School violence
Social–
ecological theory
Introduction
School violence affects all stakeholders within the school
community, but research has focused on students as vic-
tims and perpetrators. While student victimization is a
significant problem, teacher-directed violence is a critical
and under-researched concern that has yet to be consis-
tently defined. In general, it refers to a range of behav-
iors directed toward educators that include bullying and
intimidation, verbal threats, theft, and physical attacks,
which violate school rules, negatively affect school cli-
mate, and endanger the well-being of those involved in
the school (Espelage et al., 2013). In a United States
national survey of K-12 teachers across 48 states, 80%
of teachers reported being victimized at least once in the
current or past school year (McMahon et al., 2014). The
negative impact of school violence on teachers is also a
significant concern globally: large-scale studies in South
Korea (Moon, Morash, Jang & Jeong, 2015), Canada
(Wilson, Douglas & Lyon, 2011), Israel (Khoury-kas-
sabri, Astor & Benbenishty, 2009), and Slovakia (Dzuka
& Dalbert, 2007) document high prevalence of violence
and links between violence and teachers’ emotional and
behavioral functioning. Victimized teachers experience
decreased physical and emotional well-being, life satis-
faction, and teaching performance (Dzuka & Dalbert,
2007; Moon et al., 2015; Wilson et al., 2011), and
increased fearfulness and stress (Dworkin, Haney &
Telschow, 1988). Given the prevalence and negative
impact of violence directed against teachers, research is
needed to better understand teacher experiences with
violence.
✉ Susan D. McMahon
smcmahon@depaul.edu
DePaul University, Chicago, IL, USA
Am J Community Psychol (2017) 60:502–515
DOI 10.1002/ajcp.12202
ORIGINAL ARTICLE