Earthquakes and Structures, Vol. 14, No. 1 (2018) 33-44
DOI: https://doi.org/10.12989/eas.2018.14.1.033 33
Copyright © 2018 Techno-Press, Ltd.
http://www.techno-press.com/journals/eas&subpage=7 ISSN: 2092-7614 (Print), 2092-7622 (Online)
1. Introduction
Differences in the amplitudes and phase angles of the
seismic ground motions (GMs), recorded over extended
areas has been recognized for many years. In the early days,
lack of an adequately large set of recorded data prevented
quantification of the phenomenon and the development of
approaches for the incorporation of the effect into the
dynamic analysis of nuclear safety related structures
(forthcoming ASCE-4). Abrahamson (2007), in a separate
study referenced herein, presents a state-of-the-art
representation of the coherency function based on a large
number of densely spaced ground motion recordings.
Coherency functions define the relationships between
ground motion at separate locations as a function of two
parameters (1) the separation distance between the locations
and (2) the frequency of the ground motion. For coherent
motion and vertically propagating seismic waves, the
amplitude at all locations is the same such that the
coherency function is unity. For incoherent motion, the
amplitude at separated distances is different and the
coherency function is below unity (Abrahamson 2005,
2007). For fixed base NPP Horizontal and vertical ground
motions are subject to incoherency and have been included
(Abrahamson 2005, EPRI 2006).
Corresponding author, Professor
E-mail: kim2kie@kunsan.ac.kr
a
Masters Graduate
E-mail: kaiser_ce_07@kunsan.ac.kr
b
Senior Researcher
E-mail: shljrl@kepco-enc.com
Novak and Hindy (1979), Hindy and Novak (1980) were
the pioneers to introduced the ground motion’s coherency
losses as a mathematical description in the earthquake
engineering field. Early in the nineteen ninety eighties (Loh
et al. 1982, Der Kiureghian et al. 1992, Abrahamson et al.
1991, 1993) addressed the phenomenon of incoherency
based on the investigation on the earthquake acceleration
recorded over limited regions. Later, comprehensive
researches has been carried out by Luco et al. (1986) on
rigid foundation, Hao et al. (1996) on asymmetric
structures, Monti et al. (1996), Harichandran et al. (1996),
Saxena et al. (2000), Kim et al. (2003), Chakraborty and
Basu (2008), Mwafy et al. (2011) on nonlinear responses of
long span bridges, highway bridges subjected to incoherent
motions. Recently, Hossein et al. (2013) proposed method
to generate spatially varying accelerograms using neural
networks. According to Ghiocel et al. (2009) the effects of
motion incoherency on the computed In-structure-response-
spectra (ISRS) are significant for both the rock and the soil
sites for NPP structures. Sayed et al. (2015) investigated
spatial variation of El-Centro (1940) record for BI-NPP,
Adanur et al. (2016), recommended to consider incoherent
motion for suspension bridges isolated with LRBs.
Seismic (base) isolation is a mature technology in the
civil engineering realm for protecting structures from the
effects of moderate and severe earthquake shaking. Base-
isolation being limitedly used in nuclear power plants, is a
practical strategy that ensure the structural safety and
flexibility in moderate to strong earthquake. Ali Hadidi et
al. (2016) provided design of base-isolated buildings
subjected to near fault motions, Mavronicola et al. (2014)
investigated responses of bilinear LRB isolator under pulse-
like motions. In addition, Murase et al. (2013) proposed a
hybrid base-isolation system to improve seismic performances
Effect of the incoherent earthquake motion on responses
of seismically isolated nuclear power plant structure
Kaiser Ahmed
1a
, Dookie Kim
1
and Sang H. Lee
2b
1
Department of Civil Engineering, Kunsan National University, Gunsan-si, 54150, Republic of Korea
2
Power Engineering Research Institute, KEPCO E&C, Gimcheon, Republic of Korea
(Received November 22, 2016, Revised January 15, 2018, Accepted January 20, 2018)
Abstract. Base-isolated nuclear power plant (BI-NPP) structures are founded on expanded basemat as a flexible floating
nuclear island, are still lacking the recommendation of the consideration of incoherent motion effect. The effect of incoherent
earthquake motion on the seismic response of BI-NPP structure has been investigated herein. The incoherency of the ground
motions is applied by using an isotropic frequency-dependent spatial correlation function to perform the conditional simulation
of the reference design spectrum compatible ground motion in time domain. Time history analysis of two structural models with
486 and 5 equivalent lead plug rubber bearing (LRB) base-isolators have been done under uniform excitation and multiple point
excitation. two different cases have been considered: 1) Incoherent motion generated for soft soil and 2) Incoherent motion
generated for hard rock soil. The results show that the incoherent motions reduce acceleration and the lateral displacement
responses and the reduction is noticeable at soft soil site and higher frequencies.
Keywords: incoherent earthquake motion; base-isolated nuclear power plant; seismic response