Eur J Educ. 2018;1–13. wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/ejed
|
1 © 2018 John Wiley & Sons Ltd
DOI: 10.1111/ejed.12298
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Working class educational transitions to
university: The limits of success
Diane Reay
Faculty of Education, University of
Cambridge, Cambridge, United Kingdom
Correspondence
Diane Reay, Faculty of Education, University
of Cambridge, 184 Hills Road, Cambridge CB2
8PQ, United Kingdom.
Email: dr311@cam.ac.uk
Abstract
Educational transitions experienced within a context of
wide and growing inequalities such as England result in
very different transition experiences to those experienced
by young people growing up in relatively equitable socie‐
ties with strong communal links. Transitions of working
class young people in England are beset with competition,
individualism and low expectations. Employing Pierre
Bourdieu’s concepts of habitus, capital and field, the arti‐
cle argues that working class transitions to university re‐
veal the failure of the English educational system to
provide anything like a level playing field to support work‐
ing class young people who are seen to be educational
successes. Focusing on those working class young people
who are particularly successful by gaining access to elite
universities the paper argues that even this small select
group face discrimination, set‐backs, and a degree of social
exclusion. The paper concludes that the vast majority of
working class young people, including many of those who
are the most academically successful have very different
transitions to higher education, and experiences within it,
from their middle and upper class peers.
1 | INTRODUCTION: CONCEPTUALISING TRANSITIONS
For Ball, Maguire, and Macrae (2000), understandings of young people’s educational transitions need to focus on
key contextualising aspects as well as the processes involved. They argue that time and place are pivotal to the
ways in which transitions are experienced, but so also are wider dominant discourses and the broader social and
political landscape. They single out the culture of individualism and the economics of individualisation alongside