International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e-ISSN: 2395-0056
Volume: 05 Issue: 10 | Oct 2018 www.irjet.net p-ISSN: 2395-0072
© 2018, IRJET | Impact Factor value: 7.211 | ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal | Page 237
COMPERATIVE ANALYSIS OF THREE MAJOR TYPE OF CONTRACTS WITH
CASE STUDY
Abhijit Langhe
1
, Pravin Minde
2
1
M.E Student (Construction Management), PVPIT Engineering College, Pune, Maharashtra, India.
2
Assistant Professor, Dept. of Civil Engineering, PVPIT Engineering College, Pune, Maharashtra, India.
----------------------------------------------------------------------***---------------------------------------------------------------------
Abstract - The thirteenth FYP shows large interest in
investments in infrastructure sector by India, so there is need
for different types of contract that will satisfy the purpose.
Engineering, procurement and construction (EPC) contracts
are on the way to become the most usual form of contracting
applied by the private sector to undertake construction works
on large scale infrastructure projects like roads,
telecommunication, petroleum, real estate etc. In every
project, it is necessary to have good contract management in
place; otherwise it can have negative consequences for all
parties involved – the client, contractor, lenders, government,
etc. Here the contractor carry’s out the designs of project,
procure materials and equipment’s required as per the
specifications and delivers the project in agreed duration of
time. If contract management is not implemented and
controlled properly, it may have a negative impact on the
project as a whole. Such failures may include a delayed
schedule, cost overruns, quality, safety and more.
It was also found that the EPC contracting scheme could work
very well, especially in the cases where the contractor is in a
good position to understand all legal aspects of the contract,
including the allocation of risks.
A comparative study between PPP, Item Rate and Lump-Sum
mode of contract will enable to know the feasible mode of
contract in India. It lists certain advantages, disadvantages
and their need in contract.
Key Words: Contracts, EPC Contract, Lump-Sum
Contract, Item Rate Contract, Contract Comparison.
Construction industry is rapidly growing and therefore
requires various models of contracting. For mega
infrastructure projects a flexible and effective method is
needed. Engineering Procurement Construction (EPC)
contract is a popular type of contract for infrastructure and
power projects. EPC contractors carryout designs, procure
the material and equipment’s as per the specifications and
deliver the project in stipulated time.
Following factors are considered to measure the execution of
project. Time, Cost, Quality, Cost-overrun, Time- overrun,
Unit cost of building, Rate of construction, Client satisfaction
EPC contracts will continue to be the predominant form of
construction contract and will be used on large scale
infrastructure projects in most jurisdiction. EPC contracts
vary on the basis of the assignment of responsibility and
related penalties.
2. LITERATURE REVIEW:-
According to Ashwini Wadedwer, Shreedhar Patil (December
2015). The PPPs are good projects which deliver value for
money when they are toll financed. The design and
construction risk to private partners. The EPC contract plays
vital role in infrastructure development.
Due to investment of private partners in PPP, risk is more to
private sector, mainly to the lenders or financers which goes
into bad loans and delay in project completion. Because of
these risk factors nowadays there is low interest from the
investors in PPP. Therefore government is moving towards
the EPC mode as it has fixed time limit with fixed cost.
3. OBJECTIVE:-
1. To determine most suitable type of contract for
construction of flyover/road.
2. To compare three different types of contracts of same
organization.
3. To identify factors causing loss or profit of project.
4. METHODOLOGY:-
Fig-1 Methodology Flow Chart
1. INTRODUCTION