Citation: Pennick MO, Kalia A, Harris O, Barker D, Jois RHS, Audisio RA. Ultrasound Characteristics of Triple
Negative Breast Cancer - A Case Series and Review of the Literature. Austin J Clin Diag Res. 2016; 1(1): 1001.
Austin J Clin Diag Res - Volume 1 Issue 1 - 2016
Submit your Manuscript | www.austinpublishinggroup.com
Pennick et al. © All rights are reserved
Austin Journal of Clinical & Diagnostic
Research
Open Access
Abstract
Purpose: Breast cancers are subdivided according to biological sub-types
and commonly with reference to their expression (or lack thereof) of specifc
receptors - Oestrogen (ER), Progesterone (PR) and Her2-neu (HER2). Their
behavior is infuenced by receptor subtype, with triple negative status (TRN)
conferring the worst overall prognosis. It is benefcial to recognize the malignant
features of breast change, but appropriate treatment cannot be initiated based
on Ultrasound (US) scan fndings. The purpose of this study was to evaluate
our own series of TRN cancers, their ultrasound characteristics and perform a
literature review pertaining to this topic.
Results: Our series included sixty patients with TRN breast cancer. We
found that shape was not a reliable predictor of TRN status. We found the
majority of TRN cancers were of non-parallel lie (83%), had irregular margins
(68%), were hypoechoic (70%) and showed posterior enhancement (65%).
None of the cases in our series showed surrounding’s tissue change. Micro-
calcifcations were absent in 92%. Eleven articles and one book chapter were
reviewed after a literature search (total of 582 patients). We found little consensus
between authors regarding US characteristics in TRN breast cancer. There was
a predilection for irregular shape, abrupt lesion boundary, hypoechoic features
and posterior enhancement. Micro-calcifcations were absent in the majority of
cases.
Conclusions: We found little evidence supporting the claims of previous
authors that TRN cancers can be identifed by specifc ultrasound characteristics.
Tissue diagnosis cannot be replaced by imaging investigations; for any kind of
cancer treatment histology is and will be mandatory.
Keywords: Triple Negative; Breast Cancer; Ultrasound; Imaging
the statistical analysis of questionable value.
In this study, we have reviewed the literature and report our
experience with ultrasonic features of TRN tumour type at our
institute.
Materials and Methods
Patients selection
A consecutive series of patients who had triple negative breast
cancer were identifed from our institutional database in between
2008-2012. Two dedicated breast radiologists analyzed their image
characteristics. Any correlation between ultrasonographical features
was compared against the fndings highlighted by the published
relevant literature.
Immunohistochemical analysis
Hormonal (Oestrogen & Progesterone) and Her-2 status of the
cancers were analyzed on core biopsy using standard available kits
and were retested when negative on excision specimen.
Ultrasound analysis
Te ultrasound scans were performed using Voluson 730 Expert,
GE with a high resolution 12 MHz linear probe. Te ultrasound images
were then analyzed retrospectively by a single breast radiologist with
Abbreviations
TRN: Triple Negative; USS: Ultrasound; DCIS: Ductal Carcinoma
in Situ; ER: Oestrogen Receptor; PR: Progesterone Receptor; HER2:
Human Epidermal Growth Factor 2; FNA: Fine Needle Aspiration
Introduction
Te management of breast cancer and its prognosis is dependent
on numerous biological and molecular variables. Cancers which
do not express receptors for Oestrogen (ER), progesterone (PR) or
human epidermal growth factor 2 (HER2, previously ERBB2) are
termed triple negative (TRN). TRN cancers tend to occur in younger
women and confer a worse prognosis than the other breast cancer
subtypes. Early identifcation of these TRN subtypes could facilitate
aggressive therapy and hence better outcomes.
Some recent publications have looked at image characteristics
of TRN cancers and the diagnostic accuracy of diferent imaging
modalities in predicting triple negative status. Literature reports TRN
cancers exhibit certain specifc morphological features, which could
assist quicker TRN tumour type diagnosis before the histology reports
are available. However, there is a lack of consensus amongst authors
regarding which features that are typical of TRN disease. Moreover
the studies have tended to be of small sample size, which has made
Research Article
Ultrasound Characteristics of Triple Negative Breast
Cancer - A Case Series and Review of the Literature
Pennick MO
1
*, Kalia A
2
, Harris O
3
, Barker D
4
, Jois
RHS
1
, Audisio RA
1,5
1
Department of Surgery, St Helens & Knowsley NHS
Trust, St Helens Hospital, England
2
Department of Surgery, Southport & Ormskirk NHS
Trust, Southport District General Hospital, England
3
Department of Radiology, St Helens & Knowsley NHS
Trust, Whiston Hospital, England
4
Department of Pathology, St Helens & Knowlsey NHS
Trust, Whiston Hospital, England
5
University of Liverpool, England
*Corresponding author: Mandana O Pennick,
Department of Surgery, St Helens & Knowsley NHS
Trust, St Helens Hospital, England
Received: July 20, 2016; Accepted: August 19, 2016;
Published: August 23, 2016