E&S GALLEY PROOF
1 © Ernst & Sohn Verlag für Architektur und technische Wissenschaften GmbH & Co. KG, Berlin · Bauphysik 31 (2009), Heft 5
The need for optimal ventilation of office spaces in Germany
compels the designer to respect strict requirements on air quality
as stated in the German Standard DIN EN 13779. In the present
field work, an extensive survey is made in 270 work spaces be-
longing to 30 office buildings of various German cities, in which
notable differences have been observed between the lineaments
of the norm and the diagnosis issued by the users in regards to
air quality. The purpose of the present work is to define the opti-
mal concentration levels of carbon dioxide (CO
2
) on the basis of
comparing the objective date obtained through measurements
and the subjective data collected with a questionnaire responded
to by the space users. The evaluation of the air quality level using
the norm’s criterion and the mean vote of users allows the deter-
mination of the percent value of users unsatisfied with the air
quality in relation to the mean concentration levels of CO
2
. The
research method consists of user inquiries, in the form of a short
questionnaire, while making brief measurements on site with a
mobile unit equipped with CO
2
and TVOC (Total Volatile Organic
Compounds) sensors. As the most relevant result it can be noted
that, as long as the CO
2
concentration levels do not rise above
1,200 ppm, the users are incapable of discerning any decrease
in air quality of the workspace. The minimum percentage of dis-
pleased users about air quality is about 30 %.
Luftqualität in Bürogebäuden auf Basis von Messungen und Nut-
zerbefragungen. Zur Sicherstellung einer optimalen Lüftung von
Arbeitsräumen ist der Planer in Deutschland zur Einhaltung der
strengen Anforderungen an die Luftqualität aus DIN EN 13779 ge-
zwungen. In der vorliegenden Arbeit wird vor Ort eine umfangrei-
che Untersuchung von 270 Arbeitsräumen in 30 Bürogebäuden
durchgeführt. In Bezug auf die Luftqualität wurden zwischen der
Richtlinie und dem Nutzerempfinden deutliche Unterschiede fest-
gestellt. Der Zweck der Untersuchung ist die Definition der opti-
malen Konzentration von Kohlendioxid (CO
2
) auf Grund des Ver-
gleichs zwischen objektiven Daten von Messungen und subjekti-
ven Daten aus der Befragung der Nutzer von Arbeitsräumen. Die
Bewertung der Luftqualität mit Hilfe der Norm und des mittleren
Votums der Nutzer ermöglicht die Bestimmung der prozentualen
Nutzerunzufriedenheit mit der Luftqualität in Abhängigkeit von
den durchschnittlichen CO
2
-Konzentrationen. Die Untersuchung
besteht aus der Auswertung kurzer Fragebögen und Messungen
mit einer mobilen Einheit, die mit CO
2
- und TVOC-Sensoren (Total
Volatile Organic Compounds) ausgestattet ist. Als wichtigstes Er-
gebnis kann festgestellt werden, dass solange die CO
2
-Konzen-
tration nicht über 1.200 ppm steigt, die Nutzer nicht in der Lage
sind, eine Verringerung der Luftqualität in den Arbeitsräumen zu
empfinden. Der geringste Anteil der auf Grund der Luftqualität
unzufriedenen Nutzer liegt bei 30 %.
1 Introduction
In Germany, the evaluation of air quality is supported by
setting limits to the concentration of carbon dioxide (CO
2
),
as proposed by the standard [1] originated in [2]. In addi-
tion to this gas, there are substances in the form of gases
combined with dust and particles suspended in the air, na-
mely, the Volatile Organic Compounds or VOC, which can
adversely affect the air quality and become a hazard to the
health. Possible sources may be found in the materials
used in construction, the furniture and office equipment,
the low ratio of air replenishment and circulation, the ac-
tivities of users (e.g., hobbies), the emission of biogases, ci-
garette smoke and, in some instances, the external air [3].
The summation of all organic substances suspended in air
is known as the Total Volatile Organic Compounds (TOVC).
Until present there is neither an exact definition of TVOC
nor quantitative results to allow determining the hazard
levels posed by the concentrations.
The users of workspaces are not passive subjects in
regards to the air they have to breathe. Therefore, it is nor-
mal that they react to changes in air quality in ways simi-
lar to changes in weather, for example, by adapting their
clothing, opening or shutting windows, or using shading
devices against strong solar radiation [4]. In general, these
variations are sensory perceptions of the individual. How-
ever, there are gases and substances that are not perceived
when they occur at low concentrations, yet they may pose
some risk to the user‘s health, as stated by [3]. The CO
2
and TVOC parameters are capable of affecting the con-
centration and overall efficiency of users in a work space.
On these accounts, the level of ventilation or air change
rates within an indoor space could be considered a varia-
ble of economic type [5].
The purpose of this air quality evaluation method for
office buildings is to obtain a survey focused on the condi-
tions of real workspaces and the perceptions of users on
the air quality of those spaces. The method is based on a
series of measurements taken with a mobile device featur-
ing several sensors along with the simultaneous answers of
air-quality questionnaires responded to by the users. They
submit their votes on air quality and respond about the in-
fluencing factors (weather-related and other causes) that
affect their workspaces [6]. For the analysis, a database is
built on information from 270 workspaces and the diagno-
sis of 1095 air quality votes surveyed from 30 office build-
Indoor air quality defined by measurements and
questionnaires in office buildings
Ernesto Kuchen
M. Norbert Fisch
Marlon Lea ˜o
Érika Borges Lea ˜o
Fachthemen
Bauphysik /2009 druckfrei nach Korrektur druckfrei
Aufsatz-Nr. 713
Datum, Unterschrift
DOI: 10.1002/bapi.200910000