Feedback sessions as mediation spaces: empowering teacher
candidates to deepen instructional knowledge and engage
in the construction and transformation of theory in practice
Sarina Chugani Molina and Joi A. Spencer
TESOL, Literacy, & Culture Program, Department of Learning and Teaching, University of San Diego, San
Diego, CA, USA
ABSTRACT
The process of engaging in classroom research provides teacher
candidates with opportunities to enter into the kind of deep, self-
refective work that we believe is an important capacity to build in
teachers as they begin to engage in the construction and trans-
formation of theory and knowledge within their own unique con-
texts. Our Action Research (AR) process involves multiple
opportunities throughout their coursework, advising, and feed-
back sessions to try to promote the development of this capacity.
These opportunities serve as a holding space where candidates are
both supported and challenged through interactions with their
research advisors, other faculty members, their peers, and pane-
lists consisting of educators from the feld. In this paper, we
present what we believe to be important elements of AR that
emerged from our fnal feedback sessions with 13 teacher candi-
dates in our program as they prepared for the professional pre-
sentations. We found that considering these feedback sessions as
mediation spaces (1) empowers teacher candidates to externalize
and deepen� personal understandings of their research through
dialogical discourse w � ith expert others, and (2) negotiate their
power and emerging practitioner researcher identities. This feed-
back practice not only transforms the teacher candidates’ under-
standing of themselves and their practice but also opens up
opportunities for internal and external evaluation for all those
involved alongside them in the process. �
ARTICLE HISTORY
Received 8 January 2018
Accepted 10 December 2018
KEYWORDS
Action research; teacher
education; teacher
development; reflective
practice; practitioner
research; developmental
feedback
I. Introduction
In our department, teacher candidates with access to classrooms are highly encouraged
to select Action Research (AR) as their capstone projects. We believe that if our goal is to
prepare candidates to be thoughtful practitioners, then the experience provided by AR
for engaging in iterative cycles of practice as informed by student needs is a valuable
aspect of their preparation. In addition to this, it may also be the only opportunity that
they might have for the kind of sustained coaching and insight into their thinking
process and teaching practice before they exit the program. The process for engaging
in the cyclical process of assessing, teaching, refecting and sharing each of these
CONTACT Sarina Chugani Molina sarina@sandiego.edu
EDUCATIONAL ACTION RESEARCH
https://doi.org/10.1080/09650792.2018.1564685
© 2018 Educational Action Research
C/e: xx C/e QA: xx