Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Journal of Anthropological Archaeology
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jaa
Thepersistenceofplace:Hunter-gatherermortuarypracticesandland-usein
the Trent Valley, Ontario
Samantha Walker
McGill University, Canada
ARTICLEINFO
Keywords:
Ontario archaeology
Geographic information systems
GIS
Hunter-Gatherers
Geospatial modelling
Eco-Cultural Niches
Spatial analysis
Mortuary archaeology
Hopewell
Late Archaic
Middle Woodland
Southern Ontario
ABSTRACT
Hunter-gatherermortuarypracticesidentifiedintheTrentValleyregion,ONarehighlypatternedfortheMiddle
Woodlandperiod(400BCE-700CE),buttheimportanceofmanyofthesemortuarysitescanberecognizedasfar
back as the Late Archaic period (2500–1000 BCE). A geospatial modelling approach is used to predict the
distribution of mortuary sites based on ecological factors that may have influenced land use strategies. The
assessment reveals that Late Archaic and Middle Woodland mortuary sites were primarily located near aerobic
wetlands that were likely rich in emergent plant life. The predicted suitably of mineral soil horizons, when
comparedwithTrentValleyfloodplainbehaviour,suggeststhatwildricemayhavebeenaparticularlyabundant
resource near mortuary sites. The position of wild rice in Anishinaabe traditional stories is discussed to con-
textualize its potential early food value to Indigenous occupants of the Trent Valley, prior to the resource’s
documented historic importance. The highly selective positioning of mortuary sites and their continuity within
the Trent Valley region shed light on how ancestral ties to key places were established and maintained in
precolonial hunter-gatherer societies.
1. Introduction
The investigation of ancient place-making is integral for under-
standing the cumulative processes through which precolonial hunter-
gatherers produced and maintained their respective landscapes. This
paper investigates place-making within a terrestrial and wetland fora-
ging context through a case study of mortuary site placement in the
Trent Valley region of Ontario, one of the most studied archaeological
areas in Eastern North America (Boyle, 1897; Conolly et al., 2014;
Johnston, 1968a; 1968b; Ritchie, 1949:3-18; Spence et al., 1984). The
Trent Valley is known for its concentration of Middle Woodland burial
mounds (400 BCE-700 CE) which are often associated with the Point
Peninsula culture (Byers, 2011; Kenyon, 1986; Spence et al., 1978;
Smith, 2000:365).Themoundsarespeculatedtohavebeenadjacentto
primeresourcesareas,perhapsservingasseasonalaggregationspotsfor
social and economic activities, although this has yet to be formally
tested (Conollyetal.,2014;Kenyon,1986;Spence,1986;Spenceetal.,
1990). Recent research demonstrates that the Point Peninsula mounds
are not the first elaborate burial sites to emerge in the Trent Valley, as
the region is also home to the earliest known cemetery in southern
OntarioattheJacobIsland2site(Conolly et al., 2014; Conolly, 2015),
which points to a local mortuary tradition beginning by the Late Ar-
chaic (2500–1000 BCE).
This provokes two central questions regarding early place-making
practices in the Trent Valley: Were Late Archaic and Middle Woodland
mortuary sites restricted to a shared environmental setting? And, if so,
how might mortuary site selection relate to broader landscape prac-
tices? These questions are explored through a paleoecological assess-
ment and geospatial analysis of hunter-gatherer mortuary sites in the
Trent Valley. The analysis suggests highly selective mortuary site pla-
cement near fertile wetlands, where emergent plant species – in parti-
cular wild rice – were likely abundant. The study builds on previous
theoretical frameworks in hunter-gatherer archaeology which suggest
that place-making practices often served as social signalling for co-
operative land tenure systems in areas with predictable resource pat-
ches that are otherwise regionally scarce (Buikstra and Charles, 1999;
Ingold,1986;Kelly,2001;Saxe,1970;Goldstein,1981).Theanalysisis
followed by an ethnohistoric exploration of the potential relationship
between mortuary practices and wetland resources in a mobile hunter-
gatherer landscape.
2. Background
This study considers the emergence of elaborate hunter-gatherer
mortuary sites as resulting from recursive interactions between plants,
animals, and people. These historical processes produced and
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jaa.2019.03.002
Received 22 September 2018; Received in revised form 6 March 2019
E-mail address: sam.walker@mcgill.ca.
Journal of Anthropological Archaeology 54 (2019) 133–148
0278-4165/ Crown Copyright © 2019 Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
T