Environmental Values 28 (2019): 135–140.
© 2019 The White Horse Press. doi: 10.3197/096327119X15515267418494
Focusing on Relational Matters to Overcome Duality
I am writing this editorial from a neighbourhood in the UK’s second largest
city, Birmingham, where bird song and car engines intermittently can be heard
competing for attention. While my preference is for ‘living in the sticks’, rather
than a city, I nevertheless like Birmingham for its generally down to earth,
friendly people, and its multicultural, innovative, collaborative spirit. Still, I
struggle with the urban car obsession, and polluted air. Towns and cities in
the English West Midlands are largely known for their manufacturing past,
their factories and warehouses, road and canal networks. Birmingham has the
infamous ‘original spaghetti junction’, an intertwined road interchange in the
Gravelly Hill area that connects the M6 motorway with various main and local
roads. Between 2002 and 2015, Birmingham had the second fastest growing
UK city centre population and more growth is forecast for the city over the
coming years. Like all cities there is a schizophrenic range of policies and ac-
tions trying to achieve economic prosperity – constantly seeking investment
and economic growth that adds concrete, bricks and tarmac – while claiming
to be ‘green’. It has struggled to ‘green’ new developments, maintain com-
munal spaces and provide active transport infrastructure across the city such
as traffc-free cycle networks and footpaths. Since 2015 it has been marketing
itself as a ‘biophilic’ city
1
and declaring its intent to be the UK’s frst ‘natural
capital city’.
These different ‘traits’ could also be expressed as a dichotomy between
development and nature or, more generally, between humans and nature.
Economic development is largely driven and funded by those who see nature
and environmental benefts as separate from, or an add-on to, their primary
objectives. They do not see environmental concerns as a fundamental and in-
timately connected way of thinking about place-making and relating to nature.
A few months ago, a colleague from Birmingham City University, Professor
Kathryn Moore, added an interesting proposal to the regional development
discourse: a West Midlands National Park encompassing Birmingham and the
Black Country. Here the attention shifts from a landscape dominated by in-
dustrial heritage and manufacturing to the West Midland plateau’s waterways,
parks and open landscapes. This vision has been created and impressively cap-
tured by Moore in her colour-markings of maps. Instead of highlighting roads,
trainlines and built-up areas, the lines of natural features such as rivers and
areas of heathland and forests are accentuated and elevated viewpoints marked
and envisioned as nature observatories. In her own words:
When we think of a National Park our natural inclination is to look at rural areas
but there are swathes of natural beauty right here in the heart of a metropolitan
region. For a long time the West Midlands has been viewed as a concrete jungle
1. See http://biophiliccities.org/partner-cities/birmingham-uk/