Environmental Management
DOI 10.1007/s00267-016-0809-9
Group Development and Integration in a Cross-Disciplinary and
Intercultural Research Team
Naomi Kirk-Lawlor
1
●
Shorna Allred
2
Received: 9 July 2015 / Accepted: 19 December 2016
© Springer Science+Business Media New York 2016
Abstract Cross-disciplinary research is necessary to solve
many complex problems that affect society today, including
problems involving linked social and environmental sys-
tems. Examples include natural resource management or
scarcity problems, problematic effects of climate change,
and environmental pollution issues. Intercultural research
teams are needed to address many complex environmental
matters as they often cross geographic and political
boundaries, and involve people of different countries and
cultures. It follows that disciplinarily and culturally diverse
research teams have been organized to investigate and
address environmental issues. This case study investigates a
team composed of both monolingual and bilingual Chilean
and US university researchers who are geoscientists, engi-
neers and economists. The objective of this research team
was to study both the natural and human parts of a hydro-
logic system in a hyper-arid region in northern Chile.
Interviews (n = 8) addressed research questions focusing on
the interaction of cross-disciplinary diversity and cultural
diversity during group integration and development within
the team. The case study revealed that the group struggled
more with cross-disciplinary challenges than with inter-
cultural ones. Particularly challenging ones were instances
the of disciplinary crosstalk, or hidden misunderstandings,
where team members thought they understood their cross-
disciplinary colleagues, when in reality they did not. Results
showed that translation served as a facilitator to cross-
disciplinary integration of the research team. The use of
translation in group meetings as a strategy for effective
cross-disciplinary integration can be extended to mono-
lingual cross-disciplinary teams as well.
Keywords Intercultural
●
Cross-disciplinary
●
Team
development
●
Interdisciplinary
●
Cross-cultural
Introduction
Cross-disciplinary research, defined here as research that
involves teams of scientists from different disciplines or
specialties (Aagaard-Hansen and Svedin 2009), is widely
considered necessary to address complex issues that involve
coupled social systems and earth systems, such as resource
management, water scarcity, and climate change (Bakker
2012; Carew and Wickson 2010; Jakobsen et al. 2004; Klein
2004; Metzger and Zare 1999; Mobjork 2010; Robinson
2008; Tress et al. 2007). Because coupled human-
environmental systems interactions are so complex and
interdependent, no single discipline has the tools and outlook
necessary to effectively address them. Only through cross-
disciplinary interactions, the most productive environmental
and natural resource research questions can be determined
and addressed (Klein 2004). For example, in order to address
the challenges that climate change and rising sea levels pose
for low-lying communities, social scientists, engineers, and
climate scientists often must work together across the dis-
ciplines. Following common convention (e.g. (Aagaard-
Hansen and Svedin 2009; Rosenfield 1992; Wickson et al.
* Naomi Kirk-Lawlor
nek35@cornell.edu
1
Earth and Atmospheric Sciences, 2120 Snee Hall Cornell
University, Ithaca, NY 14853, USA
2
Department of Natural Resources, 102 Fernow Hall Cornell
University, Ithaca, NY 14853, USA
Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article
(doi:10.1007/s00267-016-0809-9) contains supplementary material,
which is available to authorized users.