592 Polar Record 53 (6): 592–602 (2017). © Cambridge University Press 2018. doi:10.1017/S0032247417000584
The comforting power of Christianity: Genevieve Aupidlak’s
correspondence with Father A. Thibert (OMI) in the
Brandon Sanatorium (1954–1957)
Frédéric B. Laugrand
Department of Anthropology, Université Laval, Québec, Canada
(Frederic.Laugrand@ant.ulaval.ca)
Received February 2017
ABSTRACT. In 2010, after many interviews by the Qikiqtani Truth Commission (QTC), the Qikiqtani Inuit
Association released a report to help the public understand the impact of tuberculosis on the Inuit and thereby promote
reconciliation, a goal shared by this study. In this paper, I discuss a corpus of about 28 letters by an Inuit patient named
Genevieve Aupidlak who was treated at the Brandon Sanatorium from 1954 to 1957. The letters have been transcribed
from old syllabics and translated. Aupidlak’s story shows not only the suffering of Inuit in southern sanatoria but also the
role of Christianity and that of some missionaries—such as Father Thibert—in supporting Inuit resilience. Aupidlak’s
letters illustrate how Inuit used their Christian faith to survive and how they ascribed healing power to Christian prayer
and confession, in keeping with a much older shamanic pattern.
Introduction
Tuberculosis (TB) epidemics among Canadian Inuit have
been extensively described (see Grygier, 1994; Vanast,
1991), and many Inuit today have parents and grand-
parents who lived in southern sanatoria. This aspect of
social history, still poorly known, has been attracting the
interest of scholars. In 1991, Robin McGrath published a
rich corpus of letters, short stories, poems and songs by
Inuit about their sanatorium experiences during the 1960s.
In 2001, Frank Tester, Paule McNicoll and Peter Irniq
(2001) published a paper based on 54 letters written by
these patients in syllabics and addressed to Leo Manning,
a translator employed in the mid-1950s by Northern
Affairs. From this corpus, 41 letters written in 1956 tell
the experiences of Inuit in southern sanatoria. Analysis
revealed three main themes: (1) ‘homesickness’ (that is,
the anxiety of ‘being away’ and far from home); (2) cross-
cultural misunderstandings and loss of self-esteem; and
(3) loss of control of one’s health.
This paper is about Genevieve Aupidlak, a patient
at the Brandon Sanatorium, and takes an ethnohistorical
approach that combines written and oral sources. Both
types of source material are incomplete and fragmentary,
but her letters nonetheless offer an interesting angle. They
constitute a historical record and bring an Inuk woman’s
thoughts and experiences out into the open. For Aupidlak,
writing remained a substitute for oral communication, and
in her letters she seems to talk more than write, the spoken
word coming strongly through. Many of them are quite
long, and she speaks her mind repeatedly and in detail.
Her case might not be representative of the entire corpus,
but it does offer an original voice. It shows not only how
much an Inuk could suffer when sent south to a hospital,
but also the degree to which Christianity and some Oblate
missionaries contributed to Inuit resilience. Her case is
all the more poignant because many Inuit patients died
alone, far from their families and friends in institutions
they did not even really understand. Now, for the first
time, we can see how Inuit used their Christian faith to
survive. Aupidlak found solace in Christianity and its
strong comforting power, although her faith retained some
ambiguous elements of shamanism. Her case illustrates
how missionaries provided patients with help or comfort,
often being the only end-of-life caregivers. They would
listen to patients and write letters on their behalf, helping
them to connect with family members in the north, or
record messages from the latter and bring these back to
them, thus playing a role of social and cultural mediation.
In this paper, I will first briefly describe the extent
and seriousness of TB for earlier generations of Inuit in
northern Canada and then present Genevieve Aupidlak
and the corpus of letters I collected from Father Thibert’s
archives. In the second part of the paper I will present
most of her letters, as they provide a fascinating
narrative. Finally, I will conclude with remarks on their
religiousness, with reference to some oral accounts by
Inuit elders and to the residual presence of shamanism.
Tuberculosis in the Canadian North
An everlasting plague that deeply affected the Inuit
According to Inuit Tapiriit Kanatami (https://www.itk.
ca/publication/inuit-specific-tuberculosis-strategy, con-
sulted on 2 January 2016), the rate of TB has always been
higher in Inuit Nunangat (Inuit lands) than elsewhere in
Canada. In 2011, Inuit had a reported rate
[A]lmost 254 times the rate reported for Canadian-
born non-Aboriginals and roughly 38 times the rate
reported for Canada overall.
Although this excess risk is not new, it has increased since
the 1930s, when TB reached its first peak in Canada, and
when Aboriginal patients had no access to sanatorium
treatment and often died at home. Whereas for Canada
as a whole the death rate for TB of the respiratory system