European Journal of Prosthodontics and Restorative Dentistry (2019) 27, 1–7
ejprd.org - Published by Dennis Barber Journals. Copyright ©2019 by Dennis Barber Ltd. All rights reserved.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••
EJPRD
Influence of Ceramic
Materials on Biomechanical
Behavior of Implant
Supported Fixed Prosthesis
with Hybrid Abutment
ABSTRACT
Purpose: This study evaluated the stress distribution in different cement-retained
implant-supported prostheses with a hybrid abutment. Materials and Methods: Two
factors were evaluated: restorative material for the crown and hybrid abutment - zir-
conia, lithium disilicate and hybrid ceramic, yielding 9 combinations. For finite ele-
ment analysis, a monolithic crown cemented on a hybrid abutment was modeled and
cemented on a titanium base (Ti base). An oblique load (45°, 300 N) was applied to the
fossa bottom and system fixation occurred on the bone’s base. Results: Each struc-
ture was evaluated separately to find the possible weaknesses in geometry and fail-
ure criteria. In this context, results demonstrated a significant decrease of maximum
principal and von-Mises stresses concentration when crowns with high elastic modu-
lus are cemented onto a hybrid abutment with lower elastic modulus. Conclusions:
Considering this theoretical study for a Morse taper implant, the association of a rigid
crown with a more resilient hybrid abutment reduces the tensile stress concentration
in the restoration cervical region.
INTRODUCTION
Dental ceramics have excellent mechanical properties,
1
aesthetics,
2
bio-
compatibility and chemical stability,
1,3
promoting excellent clinical per-
formance to this material
4
in manufacturing dental prostheses. Zirconia
stabilized by yttria (Y
2
O
3
), also known as Y-TZP (yttria tetragonal zirco-
nia polycrystals), has an interesting combination of properties among
ceramic materials such as high fracture toughness,
5
high hardness and
wear resistance, chemical stability and biocompatibility.
6
The transfor-
mation toughness mechanism of Y-TZP, which is responsible for high re-
sistance to fracture, allows the preparation of partial fxed prostheses and
prosthetic abutments for implants.
1
Lithium disilicate is a type of ceramic containing vitreous phase and lithi-
um oxide in its composition, unlike polycrystalline ceramics such as zirconia,
whose composition is formed by sintered crystals and absence of a vitreous
matrix.
5
Although lithium disilicate has an elastic modulus of 64 GPa
7
and
fracture strength lower than Y-TZP (210-400 MPa and 700 GPa, respectively),
it is able to offer a more appropriate aesthetic result when resistance is
not the most relevant factor. Hybrid ceramics that are polymer infltrated
Keywords
Dental Implants
Finite Element Analysis
Material Testing
Dental Ceramics
Dental Implant-Abutment Design
Authors
Dr. João Paulo Mendes Tribst*
(DDS, MSc, PhD student)
Dr. Amanda Maria de Oliveira Dal Piva*
(DDS, MSc, PhD student)
Prof. Mutlu Özcan
§
(DDs, MSc, PhD, Professor)
Prof. Alexandre Luiz Souto Borges*
(DDS, MSc, PhD, Professor)
Prof. Marco Antonio Bottino*
(DDS, MSc, PhD, Professor)
Address for Correspondence
Dr. Amanda Maria de Oliveira Dal Piva*
Email: amodalpiva@gmail.com
* Post-Graduate Program in Restorative Dentistry
(Prosthodontic), Department of Dental
Materials and Prosthodontics, São Paulo State
University (Unesp/SJC), Institute of Science and
Technology, Brazil
§
University of Zürich, Dental Materials Unit,
Center for Dental and Oral Medicine, Clinic for
Fixed and Removable Prosthodontics and Dental
Materials Science, Zurich, Switzerland
Received: 25.04.2018
Accepted: 25.03.2019
doi: 10.1922/EJPRD_01829Tribst07