Performance Evaluation of Routing Protocols RIPng, OSPFv3, and EIGRP in an
IPv6 Network
Siti Ummi Masruroh
Department of Informatics, FST
UIN Syarif Hidayatullah
Jakarta, Indonesia
ummi.masruroh@uinjkt.ac.id
Fadly Robby
Department of Informatics, FST
UIN Syarif Hidayatullah
Jakarta, Indonesia
fadly.robby11@mhs.uinjkt.ac.id
Nashrul Hakiem
Department of Informatics, FST
UIN Syarif Hidayatullah
Jakarta, Indonesia
hakiem@uinjkt.ac.id
Abstract—A Routing Protocol is a rule that determines how
routers can communicate with each other. The development
of modern computer networks such as the Internet makes
routing protocols increasingly required to find the best and
efficient route. This study examined the performance of
routing protocols RIPng, OSPFv3, and EIGRP in an IPv6
network by using GNS3 based on parameters of throughput,
jitter and packet loss. Throughput is the actual speed of a
network, the higher the throughput then the faster the data
transfer can be completed. Jitter is the difference in the
arrival time interval between packets at the destination
node. To get a better value of QoS (Quality of Service), the
value of jitter must be kept to a minimum. Packet loss is the
number of lost data packets during the data transmission
process. To get a better QoS value, the value of packet loss
must also be kept to a minimum. The results of this research
indicate that the RIPng routing protocol has the highest
throughput value, whilst a combination of OSPFv3-EIGRP
routing protocols has the smallest jitter value. Lastly, the
RIPng routing protocol has the smallest value for packet loss
Keywords- Routing Protocol; QoS; throughput; Jitter;
packet loss; Routing Redistribution; RIPng; OSPFv3;
EIGRP
I. INTRODUCTION
In large-scale networks a complex routing protocol
plays a very important role. The task of a routing protocol
is to determine the communication channels that can pass
messages from one node to another node in order to get to
the destination node in a network. The objective of an
efficient routing protocol is to determine the best path
between the source node and the destination node, and to
maintain those lines [1]. With a routing protocol,
communication between nodes can be performed on
several different networks.
Along with the increasingly rapid development of
technology, the growth of communication networks is also
getting larger. In modern communication networks such as
the Internet network, a dynamic routing protocol is used
more often than a static routing protocol. Along with the
development of the network, it requires a dynamic routing
design that can accommodate these changes without the
intervention of the network administrator when the
network develops or changes [2].
Some dynamic routing protocols can be used in a
network, such as the Open Short Path First (OSPF),
Routing Information Protocol (RIP), the Intermediate
System to Intermediate System (IS-IS) and the Enhanced
Interior Gateway Routing Protocol (EIGRP). Each routing
protocol has its own advantages and disadvantages. The
determination and selection of routing protocols depends
on several parameters that affect the quality of a network
[3].
The growth of the Internet is very high which also
results in the depletion of the allocation of resources in
Internet protocol version 4 (IPv4). Due to the demand for
content and web-based applications that create a large
inventory, fewer and fewer IPv4 addresses are available.
IPv6 was introduced in 1994 as a solution to anticipate the
problems that existed in the address limitations of IPv4 [4].
Changes to IPv6 also encouraged the development of the
existing routing protocols to support IPv6. Some routing
protocols that support IPv6 are such as RIPng, OSPFv3,
and EIGRP.
As each routing protocol has advantages in certain
circumstances, then this research will conduct simulation
experiments of network performance by applying the
incorporation of each routing protocol to obtain a protocol
combination that has the maximum performance on the
network. It is said that the use of three or more routing
protocols can improve network efficiency [5].
This research aims to evaluate the performance of the
network using a combination of three types of dynamic
routing protocol, namely RIPng, OSPFv3, and EIGRP that
already support IPv6 with the parameters of throughput,
jitter, and packet loss. The purpose of this evaluation is to
determine the best combination of routing protocols that
can be implemented in a computer network.
II. DISCUSSION
In this research we use simulation methodology that
consist of the following stages:
A. Problem Formulation
Increasingly complex network conditions cause a
Network Administrator to look to performing a network
design with the goal of good performance. Application of a
proper routing protocol on a network can help improve
throughput and efficiency.
The performance of a network can be measured by
several variables, namely throughput, jitter and packet loss.
The application of each routing protocol has an impact on
the performance of a network. The right combination of
routing protocols can be expected to provide optimum
performance in a network.
In [5] has been discussed a performance comparison
2016 International Conference on Informatics and Computing (ICIC)
978-1-5090-1648-8/16/$31.00 ©2016 IEEE