Identifying, Understanding, and Analyzing
By Steven M. Rinaldi, James P. Peerenboom, and Terrence K. Kelly
T
he notion that our nation’s critical infrastruc-
tures are highly interconnected and mutually
dependent in complex ways, both physically
and through a host of information and com-
munications technologies (so-called “cyber-
based systems”), is more than an abstract,
theoretical concept. As shown by the 1998 failure of the Gal-
axy 4 telecommunications satellite, the prolonged power
crisis in California, and many other recent infrastructure
disruptions, what happens to one infrastructure can di-
rectly and indirectly affect other infrastructures, impact
large geographic regions, and send ripples throughout the
national and global economy.
In the case of the Galaxy 4 failure, the loss of a single tele-
communications satellite led to an outage of nearly 90% of
all pagers nationwide [1]. From an interdependency per-
spective, it also disrupted a variety of banking and financial
services, such as credit card purchases and automated
teller machine transactions, and threatened key segments
of the vital human services network by disrupting communi-
cations with doctors and emergency workers. In California,
electric power disruptions in early 2001 affected oil and nat-
ural gas production, refinery operations, pipeline transport
of gasoline and jet fuel within California and to its neighbor-
ing states, and the movement of water from northern to cen-
tral and southern regions of the state for crop irrigation
[2]-[6]. The disruptions also idled key industries, led to bil-
lions of dollars of lost productivity, and stressed the entire
Western power grid, causing far-reaching security and reli-
ability concerns [7]-[10].
December 2001 IEEE Control Systems Magazine 11
0272-1708/01/$10.00©2001IEEE
Peerenboom (jpeerenboom@anl.gov) is with Argonne National Laboratory, 9700 S. Cass Ave., Bldg. 900, Argonne, IL 60439, U.S.A. Rinaldi
is with the Air Force Quadrennial Defense Review, Washington, D.C. 20330-1670, U.S.A. Kelly is with the Executive Office of the President,
Washington, D.C. 20502, U.S.A