American and Russian Voices from Outer Space:
Constructing the Unknown in Popular Space Art
Kornelia Agnieszka Boczkowska, Adam Mickiewicz University, Poland
Abstract: This paper aims to examine the art of space travel and extraterrestrial landscape, where I inquire into the
American cultural construct of the unknown and compare it with its Soviet/Russian counterpart. A visual semiotic
analysis is based on varied space art works pervading 20th century visual media, including science and popular
magazines. The genre of space art, so far hardly explored in scholarly terms, proves to be a valuable cultural artifact,
representing an array of encoded meanings whose analysis blurs the boundaries between cultural studies, conceptual art,
semiotics, cognition and visual communication. Investigating selected works of scientists, artists or space travelers,
including Georgi Kurnin, Aleksei Leonov, Andrei Sokolov, Chesley Bonestell, David Hardy or William K. Hartmann,
aims to reveal certain cross-cultural differences between the two nations’ construction of the unknown. Its representation
sheds lights on the nations’ disparate systems of depicting yet unexplored realms of experience, generating fear and
mysticism or utilizing familiar semiotic codes to communicate ideas related to outer space. These ideas turn out to be to a
large extent culturally-determined, ranging from dread, awe, wonder and excitement to mystery, mysticism, elusiveness
and magic.
Keywords: Cultural Studies, American-Russian Studies, Space Art, Visual Grammar
he paper aims to examine the art of space travel and extraterrestrial landscape, where I
inquire into the American construct of the unknown and compare it with its Soviet
counterpart. The study is based on one hundred and twelve early space art works,
particularly those published between 1940 and 1980 in popular science magazines and science
fiction novels. Investigating selected works of space artists, scientists and space travelers,
including Nikolai Kolchitzkiy, Aleksey Leonov, Andrey Sokolov, Charles Bittinger, Chesley
Bonestell and William K. Hartmann, aims to reveal certain cross-cultural differences in the two
nations’ construction of the unknown. Its visual representation sheds light on the nations’
disparate systems of depicting yet unexplored realms of experience, generating fear and awe or
utilizing familiar semiotic codes to communicate ideas related to outer space. These ideas turn
out to be to a large extent culturally-determined, ranging from dread, awe, wonder and
excitement to mystery, mysticism, elusiveness and magic.
Methodology
The notion under investigation is that of a semiotic representation of the unknown, where the
sign, including signifieds and signifiers, as well as sign-making processes, remain the key
theoretical concepts (Crow 2010; Rose 2001). In the light of visual grammar, all space art works,
similarly to other visual images depicting possible conditions of our cosmic environment, are
iconic, that is they consist of signs in which a signifier represents a signified through a strong and
apparent resemblance. For example, a signifier of Mars, due to its outward form, will most
presumably represent a signified of Mars rather than any other concept arbitrarily or inherently
related to this signifier. Iconic space representations tend to perform three metafunctions, first
proposed by Kress and van Leeuwen (1996, 40-42), in order to fully engage in a set of meaning
making processes: i) representational metafunction which examines the represented participants
or objects within an image, ii) interpersonal metafunction which investigates the relation between
the producer, the viewer and the represented object, iii) textual metafunction which studies
complex compositional arrangements to reveal various textual meanings. Such a methodology
allows me to analyze space and astronomical art as a communicational and representational
T
The International Journal of the Image
Volume 3, 2013, www.ontheimage.com, ISSN 2154-8560
© Common Ground, Kornelia Agnieszka Boczkowska, All Rights Reserved
Permissions: cg-support@commongroundpublishing.com