Defossilization of Fossilized Pragmatic Routines:
Corpus-Driven Input-Based and Output-Based Instruction
Zia Tajeddin
1*
, Ensieh Khodarahmi
2
1*
Professor of Applied Linguistics, Allameh Tabataba‟i University, Iran;
zia_tajeddin@yahoo.com
2
Ph.D. Candidate of TEFL, Allameh Tabataba‟i University, Iran;
ensieh.khodarahmi@gmail.com
Abstract
Mainstream L2 pragmatic research has shown that pragmatic fossilization is quite
common among L2 learners at almost all levels of proficiency. This study examined
the defossilizing effect of corpus-driven activities on 10 situationally-based
pragmatic routines under two instructional conditions, i.e. input-based and output-
based treatments. Participants were 33 advanced EFL learners in two classes in a
private English language center. They received instruction in four sessions across
two weeks. Before and after the treatment, a WDCT was administered for pretest
and posttest purposes. The results of paired-samples and Independent Samples t-
tests showed that input-enhancement and output-based instructions were effective in
defossilization pragmatic routines which had a strong fossilization tendency among
learners. Both treatment tasks led to significant increases in learners‟ comprehension
and production of the routines. The output-based group; however, significantly
outperformed the input-based group in the production of the routines. The findings
indicate that pragmatic instruction can debilitate the fossilization tendencies of
pragmatic routines and that different instructional tasks have differential effects on
the production and comprehension of pragmatic routines. The pedagogical
implication of this study is that a combination of instructionally supported corpus-
based tasks would be effective for enhancing EFL learners‟ ability to comprehend
and use routines appropriately in context.
Keywords: Defossilization, Input-based instruction, Output-based instruction, Pragmatic
fossilization, Pragmatic routines
Received 24 March 2019 Accepted 28 May 2019
Available online 25 June 2019 DOI: 10.30479/jmrels.2019.10523.1317
© Imam Khomeini International University. All rights reserved.