Topological Resilience Analysis of Supply Networks
under Random Disruptions and Targeted Attacks
Wenjun Wang, W. Nick Street, and Renato E. deMatta
Department of Management Sciences
University of Iowa
Iowa City, IA 52242, USA
{wenjun-wang, nick-street, renato-dematta}@uiowa.edu
Abstract—Along with the rapid advancement of information
technology, the traditional hierarchical supply chain has been
quickly evolving into a variety of supply networks, which usually
incorporate a large number of entities into complex graph
topologies. The study of the resilience of supply networks is
an important challenge. In this paper, we exploit the resilience
embedded in the network topology by investigating in depth
the multiple-path reachability of each demand node to other
nodes, and propose a novel network resilience metric. We also
develop new supply-network growth mechanisms that reflect the
heterogeneous roles of different types of nodes in the supply
network. We incorporate them into two fundamental network
topologies (i.e. random-graph network and scale-free network),
and evaluate their resilience against both random disruptions
and targeted attacks using the new resilience metric. The exper-
imental results verify the validity of our resilience metric and
the effectiveness of our growth model. This research provides a
generic framework and important insights into the construction
and resilience analysis of complex supply networks.
I. I NTRODUCTION
The supply chain is the construction and management of
the flow of goods among suppliers, distributors, retailers,
and customers. Traditional supply chains usually maintain
a hierarchical structure with a linear flow of goods from
suppliers to customers via distributors and retailers. Due to the
globalization and fast development of technology, the basic
supply chain system has become much more sophisticated,
and it has rapidly evolved into dynamic complex networks
in which links can occur not only between units of different
types, but also between units of the same type. For example,
some large retailers may distribute goods to small retailers.
While the supply network plays such an important role in
product distribution systems, its sustainability (or say, surviv-
ability) becomes an important concern. It has also become an
interesting research topic that has drawn considerable attention
and extensive studies. Some of the challenging questions
regarding the resilience of complex supply networks are as fol-
lows. What are the principles that govern how supply networks
arise and develop? How resilient is a supply network against
random and/or targeted disruptions? How do we measure
resilience, and how is it related to the network topology? How
can we build resiliency in a supply-network design? There
are many such interesting but challenging questions regarding
the resilience analysis of complex supply networks. Previous
research [1][2] have revealed that supply networks share many
characteristics that most real-world networks commonly have,
and the graph topology of the supply network has great impact
on its resilience against disruptions.
In this paper, we first propose a new resilience metric
that captures the reachability-based robustness encoded in
the network topology in a more accurate and comprehensive
manner. Then we present new supply-network growth models
that incorporate the heterogeneous roles of units of different
types into two fundamental network topologies with various
attachment strategies. Using a military logistic network as a
case study, we analyze the resilience of different growth mod-
els by simulating the supply network under random disruptions
and targeted attacks. Experimental results verify the validity of
our resilience metric, and demonstrate the effectiveness of our
growth model. Our approach sheds light on the construction
of more realistic and robust supply networks.
II. RELATED WORK
Supply networks are often subject to various disruptions,
such as unexpected accidents, natural disasters, terrorist at-
tacks, etc. When the disruption occurs, a few units or con-
nections fail to operate at the onset, but the adverse impact
on organizational performance may propagate in the network
and eventually lead to devastating malfunction of a great
component or even the entire supply system. The resilience
analysis of supply-networks under random disruptions and
targeted attacks has received considerable managerial attention
and a lot of research work.
While conventional disruption studies focus on risk miti-
gation and contingency planning strategies [3][4], some re-
searchers investigate the resilience of supply networks from a
topological perspective. Criado et al. [5] define a quantitative
measure of network vulnerability related to the graph topology.
Using a multiagent-based simulation framework, Thadaka-
malla et al. [6] examine how different network topologies
affect the supply-network resilience against random disrup-
tions and targeted attacks in terms of clustering coefficient,
size of the largest connected component (LCC), characteristic
path length in LCC, and maximum distance in LCC. Nair
and Vidal [7] adopt the multiagent model and investigate
topology-associated supply-network robustness from the per-
spective of performance impacts in terms of inventory levels,
2015 IEEE/ACM International Conference on Advances in Social Networks Analysis and Mining
250
ASONAM '15, August 25-28, 2015, Paris, France
© 2015 ACM. ISBN 978-1-4503-3854-7/15/08 $15.00
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1145/2808797.2809325