1075
Anthropological Quarterly, Vol. 91, No. 3, p. 1075–1104, ISSN 0003-5491. © 2018 by the Institute for
Ethnographic Research (IFER) a part of The George Washington University. All rights reserved.
ARTICLE
Liquid Distinctions:
Negotiating Boundaries
Between Agriculture
and the Environment in
the Israeli Desert
Liron Shani, Massachusetts Institute of Technology
ABSTRACT
Relations between humans and “nature” have long been a focus of so-
cial research and, in particular, anthropological inquiry. In recent years,
scholars have generally dismissed the distinction between these catego-
ries as empirically and conceptually irrelevant. Based on fieldwork in an
agricultural community in the Israeli desert (2010–2015), this article shows
that the boundaries between nature and culture remain salient to social
and critical analysis that focuses on interpretive aspects of environment
and space, as well as the ongoing negotiation of these distinctions. This
research demonstrates that some actors in the Arava see environmental
preservation as part of “nature” and agricultural lands as part of “culture,”
thereby emphasizing the boundaries between the two. But their relations to
the culture/nature complex are dynamic, changing in accordance with per-
sonal circumstances, external pressures, and evolving definitions of these
categories. In this sense, the division between nature and culture is not
necessarily dichotomous, but rather a multidimensional space of Nature(s)
and Culture(s). Insofar as local actors saw the blurring of the boundaries
between agriculture and the environment as part of the development of
the agricultural economy and a means of responding to changing realities,