1 Copyright © 2018 by ASME
Draft Paper
Proceedings of the 2018 Joint Rail Conference
JRC2018
April 18-20, 2017, Pittsburgh, PA, USA
JRC2018-6166
ENVIRONMENTAL AND TRACK FACTORS THAT CONTRIBUTE TO ABRASION
DAMAGE
Kyle A. Riding
University of Florida
Gainesville, Florida, USA
Robert J. Peterman
Kansas State University
Manhattan, Kansas, USA
Spencer Guthrie
Brigham Young University
Provo, Utah, USA
Matthew Brueseke
Kansas State University
Manhattan, Kansas, USA
Hossein Mosavi
University of Florida
Gainesville, Florida, USA
Koby Daily
Kansas State University
Manhattan, Kansas, USA
Wyatt Risovi-Hendrickson
Kansas State University
Manhattan, Kansas, USA
ABSTRACT
Sites with known occurrences of mud pumping or other track
concerns were investigated to determine the prevalence of
concrete bottom tie abrasion and environmental and track
conditions that could contribute to its occurrence. Field
investigations showed that it occurs in diverse geographic
locations around the U.S. and is a source of continued
maintenance concern for railroads. Water appeared to be a
significant factor involved in concrete bottom tie abrasion.
Ballast fouling, center-binding cracking, rail surface profile
variations, and large track movement during loading was seen in
locations with concrete bottom tie abrasion. Bumps or track
stiffness changes were often found at locations of abrasion
damage. Specifically, some locations with known stiff track
conditions exhibited significant abrasion damage.
INTRODUCTION
Concrete railroad ties become frequently used in the railroad
Railroad ties are used to transmit loads from the train and rail to
the subgrade and hold rail gage. Concrete ties are used in heavy-
haul rail lines and high-speed rail lines because of their ability to
carry large, repeated loads for a very long time. Concrete ties can
last 50 years or longer when fabricated properly and the track is
properly designed, built, and maintained. In order to achieve this
lifespan, prestressed concrete tie thickness and prestressing
forces are fabricated to resist design positive and negative
bending moments. These design criteria are meant to prevent
excessive deflections and gage widening during train loading
and prevent ties from failing through breakage. If the tie section
properties change during use, there is a potential for a loss in
moment capacity, gage widening, tie breakage, and ultimately
derailment. Abrasion loss on the concrete tie sides and bottom
could provide such a moment capacity reduction.
On July 18, 2013, 10 cars on a northbound train containing
municipal solid waste derailed, causing $827,700 in damage. At
the location of derailment, the ballast was severely fouled with
gray mud. The gray mud was mostly from ground up concrete
fines from concrete ties that had lost section on the bottom. The
ties also had center-binding cracking from high negative
moments in the tie center that occurred or were worsened
because of loss of ballast support near the ends and reduced
section thickness. The investigation faulted the combination of