Proceedings of Intercultural Competence Conference August, 2010, Vol. 1, pp. 220-234
Copyright © 2010 220
EXPLORING INTERCULTURAL COMPETENCE
IN A VICTORIAN NOVEL
Frank Malgesini
Universidad Autónoma de Chihuahua
frankmalgesini@yahoo.com
Although the characters speak English, Anne Brontë’s The Tenant of Wildfell Hall
explores interactions among representatives of different speech communities. The
protagonist, Helen Graham, moves through communities differing enough from hers
to create misunderstandings. Her difficulties can be clarified through Hymes’ model
of the speech community and communicative competence, with speakers separated
by cultural assumptions rather than linguistic diversity. Helen sometimes fails to
perceive conventions that govern other participants and sometimes refuses to
submit to those conventions. She compounds her problems through several
interaction strategies, judging others by standards derived from her home
community, closing off communication when she encounters unexpected responses,
preferring solitude to social interaction and communicating through writing rather
than face-to-face encounters. These strategies limit Helen’s integration because
she remains unaware of her neighbor’s conventions, inadvertently provoking
hostility through unconventional conduct and because she uses her own
conventions as standards for judging others. Her avoidance of encounters limits her
opportunity to improve interaction skills. Helen’s experiences can help readers gain
awareness of how differing expectations and lack of empathy can cause
misunderstandings and exacerbate cultural differences. L2 readers may recognize
parallels between Helen’s experience and their own, leading to greater awareness
of issues involved in intercultural competence.
When we speak of intercultural communication we tend to focus upon interactions
between people who are native speakers of different languages. But it may be possible
for speakers of a common language to find themselves in situations where cultural
divergence leads to misunderstanding. The Tenant of Wildfell Hall by Anne Brontë
(1848/1966) recounts the history of Helen Graham during two period of her life in which
she is seeking to adapt to communities that differ from the one that she grew up in. The
first section of the novel describes her experiences in Lindenhope during the months
she lives there in 1827-1828 from the perspective of a neighbor, Gilbert Markham. The
middle section, recorded in her diary, describes her experiences from 1821 to late 1827,
ending five days after the first section began. During this period, she marries Arthur
Huntingdon and moves to her husband’s home called Grassdale. In both Lindenhope
and Grassdale Helen encounters cultural assumptions unlike those she expects.