scenario planning
Peter McKiernan
DEFINITION
Scenario planning (SP) is a process within
strategic management that combines the creation
of several stories of plausible futures with the
practical strategic responses that are required to
deal with them. The creation of stories maps the
future terrain through a systematic analysis of
the key drivers of contextual change. By focusing
on the uncertain outcomes of those drivers, SP
becomes a major component of organizational
learning.
CONCEPTUAL OVERVIEW
The original formal systems for exploring
possible future states have their origins in the
military, where anticipation of enemy action
and reaction was crucial for survival. A series
of “what if?” questions helped ready forces
for attack or defense. For the Normandy
landings … what if the beach sand does not
take the weight of the tanks? For the Maginot
line … what if the opposition comes through
the forested Ardennes or across the plains of
Belgium? Answers to such “what if?” questions
require foresight to build the possible future
states that might unfold and planning to prepare
the resource base for any consequent strategic
action.
Contemporary commercial scenario history
has followed two journeys. The frst emerged in
post-war Europe where, ravaged by destruction,
leaders were faced with rebuilding society and
recreating cultures and economies from the
grassroots. In France, Gaston Berger founded
the “Centre d’Etudes Prospectives” (CEP),
where he developed a scenario approach to
long-range planning entitled “La Prospec-
tive.” Berger believed that the future was not
predetermined, but rather something that could
be shaped to the benefts of wider society by
emphasizing positive future scenarios. By the
1960s, this approach had embraced education,
the environment, urbanization, and regional
planning. Pierre Masse (the Commissioner for
the French National Plan) incorporated it into
the fourth French National Plan (1960–1965).
Subsequent iterations of the CEP methodology
focused on infuencing key political groups
and specifying ways in which these futures
could improve the lives of ordinary people (de
Jouvenal, 1967) and the development of fresh
tools and techniques, including pioneering
computer simulation, after the arrival of defense
analyst Michel Godet in the 1970s.
The second journey fows from the US mili-
tary during World War II when, coupled with
the usual “what if?” questions above, leaders
were faced with a mismatch between military
planning based on past wisdom and the rapid
throughput of ingenious new technology that
would shape the future domain of warfare. After
the war, the RAND Corporation was established
to bridge traditional military planning and
technological R&D. In the 1950s, its “systems
theory” approach was extended from defense
studies into social issues such as urban decay
and poverty. Herman Kahn, one of RAND’s
infuential thinkers, set up the Hudson Institute
in 1961 where his foresightful studies speculated
on the “World of 2000.” Kahn’s conjectures
were based mainly on the analysis of the long-
term trends, for example, population growth
and their impact at key stages in societal devel-
opment. He coined the term “scenarios” for the
resultant futures – a term used in Hollywood
for the complete script and shooting directions
of a motion picture. Ironically, in thinking the
unthinkable about thermonuclear warfare, the
Dr Strangelove character in Kubrick’s 1963 flm
of the same name, was based on Kahn. Kahn
saw scenarios as:
“A hypothetical sequence of events for the
purpose of focusing attention on causal processes
and decision points.” Kahn (1965).
Hudson’s research attracted a variety of
multinational companies, including the Shell
Corporation that is credited widely with the
frst commercial applications of Kahn-based SP.
But the highly formalized “Unifed Planning
Machinery” (UPM) had dominated Shell’s
prospecting of the future since 1961. As the oil
price became subject to increasing uncertainty,
the forecasting-based UPM began to struggle.
Pierre Wack (from Shell Français) and Ted
Newland led its small team in the early 1970s
that introduced Kahn’s scenario stories into
the planning process and argued that this was
Wiley Encyclopedia of Management, edited by Professor Sir Cary L Cooper.
Copyright © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.