An exploratory account of the register
of nursing textbooks
Can you nurse from them?
Alexandra I. García
Te University of Sydney
Given the pressing issues that afect nursing education (e.g. higher attrition
and plagiarism rates), this study aims to obtain initial insight on whether
nursing textbooks meet the demands of their context of situation. Tese
demands could be listed as: construing biomedical knowledge, establishing
a pattern of evidence-based nursing practice and promoting the values of
person-centred care. For this analysis, I draw on aspects of parameters of
context developed by Hasan (2004), Butt (2004) and Matthiessen (2015),
and relate them to their semantic and lexicogrammatical realisation across
diferent metafunctions using corpus-based techniques and detailed manual
analysis of short extracts. Te results may suggest that nursing textbooks
may be meeting the demands of nursing as a research-based discipline but
failing to model empathetic communication.
Keywords: nursing textbooks, context of situation, register, generic
structure, technicality, a research-based discipline, empathetic
communication, construal of knowledge, epistemological stance, narrative
1. Introduction
While undergraduate textbooks may be an undervalued register as compared to
other scholarly registers (e.g. journal articles), they play a crucial role in building
diferent types of disciplinary knowledge. To begin with, textbooks are a reposi-
tory of well-established facts or theories of a discipline. Tis does not necessarily
preclude them (or at least it should not) from introducing students to the dis-
cipline’s epistemological stance, its ways of knowing and its attitude towards the
construal of new knowledge. Tere is already some evidence of textbooks intro-
ducing knowledge as contested and evolving (Hyland 2000; Love 2014). Further-
more, and perhaps of more interest to the linguist, textbooks model the diferent
https://doi.org/10.1075/langct.00003.gar
Language, Context and Text 1:1 (2019), pp. 39–64. issn 2589-7233 | e‑issn 2589-7241
© John Benjamins Publishing Company