The permeability of tag questions
in a language contact situation
The case of Spanish-Portuguese bilinguals
Ana M. Carvalho and Joseph Kern
University of Arizona | The University of Virginia’s College at Wise
In this paper, we utilize negative polarity tag questions in order to assess to
what extent discourse-pragmatic variables are susceptible to language
contact induced changes. Based on a comparison of forms and functions of
negative tags in the varieties spoken by Portuguese-Spanish bilinguals in a
community on the Uruguayan-Brazilian border with the one spoken by
monolinguals in the Uruguayan capital, we aimed at assessing to what
extent any diferences in this variable behavior may be afected by contact
with Portuguese. Our results indicate that, despite the high permeability of
discourse-pragmatic features in contact situations attested in the literature
and the presumed tendency for cognate languages to converge, the forms
and functions of negative tags in bilingual Spanish did not radically difer
from the monolingual variety. We found, instead, an intricate pattern of
convergences and divergences that challenges the presupposed assumptions
about extreme permeability of cognate discourse pragmatic systems in
contact.
Keywords: language contact, discourse markers, tag questions,
bilingualism, Portuguese, Spanish, border
1. Introduction
There is plenty of evidence by now that discourse-pragmatic features can be
extremely permeable and susceptible to borrowing in bilingual discourse (Dajko
and Carmichael 2014; Myers-Scotton and Jake 1995, among others). This counters
the generalization that only content words such as nouns, verbs, and adjectives
are likely to be borrowed in contact situations. By framing discourse organization
as opposed to participating in sentence formation, discourse-pragmatic features
may be expected to be highly permeable since they can be freely incorporated
https://doi.org/10.1075/prag.18068.car | Published online: 21 August 2019
Pragmatics issn 1018-2101 | e‑issn 2406-4238
© John Benjamins Publishing Company