© Koninklijke Brill NV, Leiden, 2019 IMAGES
Also available online—brill.com/ima DOI:10.1163/18718000-12340112
DAVID GUEDJ
DOUBLE TENDANCE: THE PHOTOGRAPHIC MESSAGE IN THE EGYPTIAN JEWISH
YOUTH MAGAZINE L’ILLUSTRATION JUIVE, 1929–1931
is evident in the prominent presence of photographs,
paintings, and sculpture reproductions in each of its
issues, all of which came complete with short cap-
tions. Scholarship has yet to engage with this unique
quarterly, with the exception of a few bibliographical
references and a handful of studies.1 I would therefore
like to dedicate this article to introducing this quarterly
to a wider scholarly audience and to providing this
audience with some historical information regard-
ing its establishment. I would also like to explore the
journal’s visual messages as shaped by the artists and
photographers, as edited by the publication’s editorial
board, and as viewed, in turn, by its young readership.2
The present analysis sets out to uncover the ideologies
and worldviews of the publication’s editorial board
along with the conscious or unconscious messages
that the quarterly strove to communicate to its readers.
I will argue that L’Illustration Juive’s visual messages
functioned to convince its Jewish Egyptian readers
that modern Jewish nationalism and Jewish religion
were inextricably linked and that their fusion was
vital to Jewish identity and to the future of the Jewish
people as a whole. Little attention has been paid to the
visual imagery that shaped and propagated the Zion-
ist project—and this is especially true with regard to
the photographic imagery. This examination of visual
messages emphasizes the role played by the visual
elements of the Jewish press in forging Jewish identity
and an imagined national Jewish community, which is
Abstract
The present article investigates the visual elements of the
illustrated youth quarterly L’Illustration Juive, which was
published in Alexandria between 1929 and 1931 in French
and Hebrew. The analysis sets out to expose the ideologies
and worldviews informing the publication’s editorial board,
as well as the conscious or unconscious message that the
quarterly tried to communicate to its young readership. The
article explores more than 300 photographs and reproductions
that featured in twelve issues published over the journal’s three
years of existence. Analysis of the visual elements in this article
shows that the quarterly featured many photographs of holy
sites in the Land of Israel, as well as reproductions of artworks
that reflected the religious Jewish way of life in the diaspora
and Israel, including the Jewish calendar and Jewish life cycle.
These works hold the Old Testament as a key book for Judaism,
as well as for Jewish nationalism. Clearly evident in the visual
elements, as in the overall visual messages of the quarterly, is
the harmony struck between Jewish nationality, Zionism, and
a religious Jewish cultural—or diasporic—world. It was this
harmonious view that editor Rabbi David Prato sought to con-
vey, upholding as he did a religious nationalist Jewish future,
which he defined in the newspaper as a double tendance.
The following article explores the visual elements
of the illustrated youth quarterly L’Illustration Juive,
which was published in Alexandria, Egypt, between
1929 and 1931 in French and Hebrew. The quarterly is
unique in Egypt and around the Muslim world due to
the importance it invested in the visual message, which
1 Generally speaking, illustrated journals were few and far
between in the Muslim world. According to Robert Attal, two
illustrated newspapers ran in Tunisia: Revue Israélite de Tunisie and
Ha-Chofar. See Robert Attal, The Periodical Jewish Press of North
Africa, ed. Mordechay Naor (Tel Aviv: Tel Aviv University, 1996),
123, 141 (Hebrew). The newspaper L’Avenir Illustré ran in Morocco
between 1926 and 1940. See David Guedj, “Portraits, Land of Israel,
and the Moroccan Jewish Communities: The Photographic Message
in the Moroccan Jewish Newspaper L’Avenir Illustré,” Pe’amim:
Studies in Oriental Jewry 150–152 (2018): 22–51 (Hebrew).
2 To date, no study has analyzed illustrations or photographs
that ran in the Jewish illustrated press. Even studies of such press
in Europe and the Land of Israel failed to engage with the visual
images, while scholarship, for the most part, has provided only
review-like writing or engagement with the texts. For studies into
illustrated press in Poland, see, for example, Lucjan Dobroszycki
and Barbara Kirshenblatt-Gimblett, Image Before My Eyes: A Pho-
tographic History of Jewish Life in Poland 1864–1939 (New York:
Schocken Books, 1977), 20–27. For studies into illustrated press
in the Land of Israel, see, for example, Tirza Shafir Binyamini,
“‘Kolno’a’, The First Illustrated Newspaper in Eretz Israel, 1931–35,”
Qesher 7 (1990): 66–70 (Hebrew). For studies that have their focus
on visual images in the press, see, for example, Max Quanchi, “The
Power of Pictures: Learning by Looking at Papua in Illustrated
Newspapers and Magazines,” Australian Historical Studies 35,
no. 123 (2004): 37–53; Thierry Gervais, “Witness to War: The
Uses of Photography in the Illustrated Press, 1855–1904,” Journal
of Visual Culture 9, no. 3 (2010): 370–384; and Guedj, “Portraits,
Land of Israel.”