Case Reports
Focal Cooling Suppresses Spontaneous Epileptiform Activity
without Changing the Cortical Motor Threshold
*Kameel M. Karkar, *Paul A. Garcia, *Lisa M. Bateman, †Matthew D. Smyth,
†Nicholas M. Barbaro, and †Mitchel Berger
Departments of *Neurology and †Neurological Surgery, University of California, San Francisco,
San Francisco, California, U.S.A.
Summary: Purpose: Focal cerebral cooling has been shown to
reduce epileptiform activity in animals. There are, however,
few reports of this phenomenon in humans.
Methods: Electrocorticography was performed before resec-
tion of a right frontal tumor in a patient with partial seizures.
Cold saline was applied to the interictal spike focus, and its
effect on the epileptiform discharges was observed.
Results: Application of cold saline to the spike focus resulted
in a transient, complete cessation of spiking. This effect was
reproduced with a second application of cold saline. The motor
threshold for electrical stimulation remained unchanged during
the application of saline.
Conclusions: In this patient with tumor-related epilepsy, fo-
cal cooling of the cortex reproducibly abolished interictal epi-
leptiform discharges without changing the motor threshold to
electrical stimulation. Key Words: Cerebral cooling—
Epileptiform—Motor threshold.
Cooling has been shown to deactivate the central ner-
vous system reversibly (1,2). In addition, several in vivo
and in vitro studies have demonstrated a reduction of
epileptiform activity in models of epilepsy after gradual
cooling (3–6). The mechanism by which this is achieved
is not clearly understood, but there is evidence of inter-
ference with synaptic transmission and voltage-gated ion
channels (7–9). There is some evidence that the antisei-
zure effect persists beyond acute abortion of seizure ac-
tivity, with demonstration of a lasting effect on cortical
irritability after two periods of cooling (5). There are,
however, few accounts of the response of epileptiform
activity in humans to cooling (10–12).
In 1969 the successful treatment of five of six patients
with medically refractory, focal status epilepticus by us-
ing general hypothermia was reported (10). Similar ac-
counts followed (11). More recently, there was a report
of rapid termination of intraoperative stimulation-
induced seizures and afterdischarges with the application
of cold Ringer solution (12). We report the first evidence
that focal cortical cooling by application of cold saline
can abolish spontaneous epileptiform activity while
maintaining intact cortical motor function.
CASE REPORT
History
A 41 year-old man was in good health until 6 years
before surgery, when he had a focal motor seizure in-
volving his left arm that progressed to a secondarily gen-
eralized tonic–clonic seizure. Magnetic resonance
imaging (MRI) revealed a right frontal mass, later deter-
mined on biopsy to be a grade II oligoastrocytoma. The
patient subsequently underwent resection of the tumor,
followed by external beam radiation treatment. He con-
tinued to have frequent brief focal motor seizures involv-
ing the left arm and leg that proved to be medically
intractable. Three months before surgery, a MRI showed
no progression of the residual tumor in the right poste-
rior–superior frontal lobe. Nevertheless, because of the
intractable seizures, surgery was performed to remove
the tumor and to resect adjacent epileptogenic tissue.
Operating room
Electrodes were placed on the cortical surface in four
rows of four, as shown in Fig. 1.
Recording from these electrodes revealed a back-
Accepted March 30, 2002.
Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr. K.M. Karkar at
Department of Neurology, University of California at San Francisco,
San Francisco, CA, U.S.A. E-mail: karkark@itsa.ucsf.edu
Epilepsia, 43(8):932–935, 2002
Blackwell Publishing, Inc.
© International League Against Epilepsy
932