International Journal of Applied Engineering Research ISSN 0973-4562 Volume 11, Number 2 (2016) pp 950-954
© Research India Publications. http://www.ripublication.com
950
Economics Analysis of Diesel and Solar Water Pumping
with Case Study Water Pumping for Irrigation in Egypt
Enas R. Shouman
Information System Department,
National Research Centre,
El Buhouth St., Dokki, Giza, Egypt.
E-mail: Shouman28@hotmail.com
E.T. El Shenawy
Solar Energy Department,
National Research Centre,
El Buhouth St., Dokki, Giza, Egypt.
E-mail: essamahame@hotmail.com
M.A. Badr
Mechanical Engineering Department,
National Research Centre,
El Buhouth St., Dokki, Giza, Egypt.
E-mail: dr_mabadr@yahoo.com
Abstract
In rural and undeveloped areas where there is no power grid and
more water is needed for agriculture purposes and human uses,
the choices for driving water pumps are usually solar via
photovoltaic or a fuel driven engine, usually diesel. There are
very distinct differences between the two power sources in terms
of cost and reliability. The present paper presents an economic
analysis of diesel and PV water pumping systems for irrigation
purposes at Cairo, Egypt (Lat. 30° 2' 38" North, Long. 31° 14' 9"
East). According to the location parameters, the required water
demand, unit cost of different components and fuel cost, the study
uses the HOMOR software and theoretical equations governing
the photovoltaic operation to get the optimal system design and
the related economic analysis. The study considered three systems
for water pumping; PV only, hybrid PV-Diesel and Diesel only.
The study showed the advantages of use photovoltaic energy over
that of the diesel generator in terms of the net present cost and the
cost of energy. It also concluded that diesel pumps are typically
characterized by a lower capital cost but a very high operation
and maintenance cost. Solar is the opposite, with a considerably
higher capital cost but very low ongoing operation and
maintenance costs.
Keywords: Water pumping, Diesel generator, Solar energy,
photovoltaic, Cost analysis.
Introduction
Water is becoming an increasingly scarce resource and become a
major problem in many countries around the world due to water
pollution, inadequate flow in some rivers and increase in demand
due to growing population, and rapid new rural and urban areas
[1]. The world growth of population and the change of land use
due to expansion in the agriculture land also increased the need of
global fresh water resources [2]. The population growth is the
major factor contributing for the increase in global pollution and
energy and water consumption [3]. Due to the global pollution,
the climate change becomes more prevalent and hence affects on
the future availability of fresh water as well as decrease of the
rainfall rates [4].
Water pumping is an energy-intensive process and most of the
world’s plants are currently powered by conventional energy
production. As the costs of fossil fuels increase, their operation
becomes increasingly expensive and with the additional costs of
pollution and greenhouse gas emissions.
Egypt, developing an electric grid system to rural and remote
areas is often too expensive because these areas are frequently
located too far away from existing grid lines. Even if fuel is
available within the country, transporting that fuel to remote,
rural areas can be difficult. There are no roads or supporting
infrastructure in many remote areas. Hence, the integration of
renewable energy production with pumping water is
increasingly attractive. A report released by the International
Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA) [5] indicated that the
costs of renewable will fall by almost 40 percent in the next
two years, and solar energy should reach grid parity in 80
percent of its market by 2017.
Egypt possesses a good potential for renewable energy
including solar, wind and biomass energy [6]. In the field of
solar energy, Egypt lie in the best sun-belt region in the
world and Egypt has the highest number of sunshine hours all
year round with higher irradiation levels. Fig.1 shows the
distribution of solar radiation in Egypt [7]. From the figure, it
is clear that higher solar radiation levels can strongly
supports the use of solar energy in development plans in
Egypt.
Figure 1: Distribution of solar radiation in Egypt.
Although the agricultural area of Egypt is extended from
33265 km
2
or 7.91 million feddan (3.3% of Egypt area) in
2003 to 37503 km
2
or 8.92 million feddan (3.7% of Egypt