History Education and the Construction of Identities, pages 139–150
Copyright © 2012 by Information Age Publishing
All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. 139
CHAPTER 10
COMMENTARY
Identity Construction and the
Goals of History Education
Cesar Lopez and Mario Carretero
A pioneering writer on the topics covered in this book, the French historian
M. Ferro (1981) affirmed in his work How the Past is Taught to Children that:
Our images of other people, or of ourselves for that matter, reflect the history
we are taught as children. This history marks us for life. Its representation
(…) of the past of societies, embraced all of our passing or permanent opin-
ions, so that the traces of our first questioning, our first emotions, remain
indelible. (p. vii)
We have discussed Ferro’s assertion a number of times in recent years, and
we must confess that we have occasionally thought it, if not wrong, at least
exaggerated. However, thirty years after the publication of the original
work, which is seminal in the field, his statement seems more accurate than
ever. The history taught in most countries (Carretero, 2011; Foster & Craw-
ford, 2006; Symcox & Wilschut, 2009) is composed of versions of the past
that in addition to giving historiographic meaning to the study of causal
temporal relationships, also amplify the nation-state’s official voice—often
(c) Information Age Publishing
Review purposes only