The journey of learning
Luca Tateo
Federal University of Bahia and Aalborg University �
ABSTRACT
The Odyssey is one of the highest products of human creation of all times. In
the book Mythos and Voice, Charles Underwood presents an innovative
perspective on this work of art, discussing the development of the main
characters by the light of psychological and anthropological theories. Then,
he discusses the dialogical theories of ontogenetic development using the
characters of Odyssey as specimen. I finally suggest that the Underwood’s
insights about the characters of Odyssey can provide fruitful hints for the
understanding of the identity enactment in contemporary societies, by
revisiting the positioning process and the dialogical construction of
identity.
As one of the peaks of human creation of all time, Homer’s Odyssey is a particularly valuable object of
study for psychology. In his book Mythos and Voice, Charles Underwood presents an innovative
perspective about and through this work of art. Underwood discusses the development of the main
characters along the course of the epic poem in the context of psychological and anthropological theories.
He discusses dialogical theories of ontogenetic development using the Odyssey as an example. I find this
endeavor extremely stimulating for the theoretical and epistemological debate in psychology. Therefore,
I do not limit myself to a traditional review to praise and discuss Underwood’s book. I would rather use it
as an opportunity to stress what I consider relevant issues for contemporary cultural psychology, for
instance: the use of literature (as well as any other product of human activity) as an object of investigation
in psychology; the developmental nature of all human psychic phenomena; and the development of the
Self in the contemporary era of popularity-based social media.
The odyssey as a polyphonic work
Despite the contemporary taste and literary standards, the Odyssey is still a remarkable piece of
literature, which has everything: romance and action, plot twists, flashbacks, great characters, and
irony. It is a polyphonic work in which at least four stories develop in parallel, namely the journey of
Odysseus, the developmental process of the young Telemakhos, the struggle of Penelope and, in the
background, the dispute between the gods, which is of no small importance when it comes to the
unfolding of the plot. According to Bakhtin, a polyphonic novel is composed by “a plurality of
independent and unmerged voices and consciousnesses” (Bakhtin, 1984, p. 6, italics in the original).
The characters of the poem develop independently in time and space, until reaching a convergence
in the final books of the poem. Some of the characters seem to be on the same plane as the author,
who in Bakhtin’s terms has always an exceeding vision (Bakhtin, 1984). In “polyphonic novels the
discourses of the characters do not come under the control of the discourse of the author” (Eun,
2018, p. 12). The initial episode of the council of the gods, shows how the author is above the
CONTACT Luca Tateo lucatateo@gmail.com
Mythos and Voice: Displacement, Learning, and Agency in Odysseus’ World, by C. Underwood, Lexington Books, September 15,
2018, 228 pp., $95 (hardcover), ISBN-10: 1498534244
Color versions of one or more of the figures in the article can be found online at www.tandfonline.com/hmca.
© 2019 Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
MIND, CULTURE, AND ACTIVITY
https://doi.org/10.1080/10749039.2019.1686028