Green roofs in Mediterranean areas e Survey and maintenance
planning
Cristina Matos Silva
*
, In
^
es Flores-Colen, Ana Coelho
Department of Civil Engineering and Architecture and Georesources, Instituto Superior T ecnico, University of Lisbon, Av. Rovisco Pais,1049-001, Lisbon,
Portugal
article info
Article history:
Received 21 May 2015
Received in revised form
16 July 2015
Accepted 28 July 2015
Available online 1 August 2015
Keywords:
Green roofs
In-service survey
Maintenance planning
Mediterranean area
abstract
This paper addresses green roof maintenance in Mediterranean areas. A field survey is presented,
describing building and roof systems of eleven case studies in Portugal, anomalies, causes and mainte-
nance actions. The most affected system components were the vegetation layer, followed by the drainage
system, substrate and paths. All inspected green roofs have regular maintenance, mainly concerning
gardening operations, but a large dispersion in terms of frequency and type of maintenance actions was
identified. The study confirmed that some design recommendations were not followed, especially the
ones associated with singular points, accesses and safety measures. In-situ results were then used to
propose a maintenance plan, structured for each system component, corresponding service life predic-
tion and type of maintenance action. The inclusion of the real needs of in-service green roofs in Medi-
terranean climate, with specific requirements for irrigation and cleaning, led to a more accurate
definition of the maintenance actions and their frequency. The responsible person for each maintenance
action is indicated. That helps to minimize overall costs, pathology and risks.
© 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Green roofs were long-established due to their ornamental
value while other positive contributions of this constructive solu-
tion have been neglected. In the last decades, green roofs have
become more popular and various studies now focus on the ben-
efits associated with this roof constructive solution, e.g., the critical
analysis of Berardi [1] for a general review. This integrated system
can help to achieve high performance buildings and sustainable
built environments, since green roofs absorb rainwater [2], air [3]
and noise [4] pollutions, provide additional insulation [5], low ur-
ban air temperatures [6] and create a habitat for wildlife [7], among
other local and urban benefits.
In order to assure green roofs benefits, this constructive solution
should be correctly designed and maintained along its life cycle [8].
This also helps minimizing risks, such as fire [9,10] and ensures the
longevity of the constructive system [11].
Several technical documents define the need of accurate design
and predict maintenance actions for green roofs. Most of them
follow the recommendations defined in the FLL Roof Greening
Guideline [12] from Germany, widely accepted abroad, e.g., UK
[10,13], Canada [8,9,11], Semi-Arid and Arid West [14], France [15]
or Australia [16]. Normas Tecnol ogicas de Jardinería NTJ [17] are
also based on FLL with application to Mediterranean areas (Spain).
These references identify the need of a maintenance plan for
owners, users and building managers to assure the good in-service
performance of a green roof. Some define regular maintenance
measures of the roof [9], such as cleaning or watering. The need of
distinct maintenance requirements in extensive and intensive
green roofs is also referred [12]. However, a detailed maintenance
plan, with a description of maintenance actions and their fre-
quency, is rarely found in the literature, standards or guidelines.
This situation does not help the dissemination of green roofs
constructive solutions, since owners and decision-makers will not
feel comfortable in choosing this constructive solution.
Maintenance varies from one region to another according to the
local climate [18]. Green roof technology in Mediterranean regions
is not stabilized as in continental Europe or the US. In fact, popular
misconceptions are commonly referred e.g. in Malta, Italy or France
[19,20]. Particular specifications of Mediterranean climate, such as
hot and dry summers and mild to cool wet winters, high wind and
solar radiation exposures or irregular rainfall pattern, should
* Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: cristina.matos.silva@tecnico.ulisboa.pt (C.M. Silva), ines.flores.
colen@tecnico.ulisboa.pt (I. Flores-Colen).
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Building and Environment
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/buildenv
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.buildenv.2015.07.029
0360-1323/© 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Building and Environment 94 (2015) 131e143