The scientific and affective
identification of Republican
civilian victims from the
Spanish Civil War
Layla Renshaw
Kingston University, UK
Abstract
This article addresses the concurrent processes of the scientific and affective identification of
human remains, resulting from the excavation of mass graves from the Spanish Civil War. Affective
identification refers to the reconstruction of locally meaningful identities, recognition amongst
the living of affective bonds with the dead, and the emotions of mourning elicited in this process.
Drawing on fieldwork in two rural communities in the Burgos region of Spain, it follows the
exhumation of mass graves containing the human remains of local Republican civilians, victims of
extrajudicial killings during the Spanish Civil War. The long time lapse between these deaths and
current exhumations place these events on the boundaries of living memory, creating challenges for
the investigative process. Widespread experiences of political repression during Spain’s dictatorship
have resulted in a fractured transmission of memories of the dead, making the question of affective
and familial bonds with the dead more complex for these communities.
Keywords
exhumation, identification, memory, mourning, Spanish Civil War
Introduction
The Spanish Civil War (1936–9) was triggered by a military coup headed by General
Franco against a democratically elected leftist government. The war was fought on bat-
tlefields between Francoist and Republican military forces, but was also marked by a
very high number of non-combatant deaths, comprised of both civilians and prisoners of
war (Congram and Steadman, 2008). It has been estimated that at least 150,000 people
were killed away from the battlefields during the Civil War and in the first decade of
Corresponding author:
Layla Renshaw, Life Science, Kingston University, Penrhyn Road, Kingston KT1 2EE, UK.
Email: l.renshaw@kingston.ac.uk
Article
Journal of Material Culture
15(4) 449–463
© The Author(s) 2010
Reprints and permission: sagepub.
co.uk/journalsPermissions.nav
DOI: 10.1177/1359183510382961
http://mcu.sagepub.com
Journal of
MATERIAL
CULTURE