Chemical Engineering Journal 164 (2010) 425–431
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Chemical Engineering Journal
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/cej
Relationship between mechanical properties and shape descriptors of granules
obtained by fluidized bed wet granulation
Darío I. Téllez-Medina
∗
, Edmond Byrne, John Fitzpatrick, Muammer Catak, Kevin Cronin
Department of Process and Chemical Engineering, University College Cork, College Road, Cork, Ireland
article info
Article history:
Received 3 July 2009
Received in revised form
12 November 2009
Accepted 27 November 2009
Keywords:
Wet granulation
Coefficient of restitution
Granule strength
Fractal dimension
Lacunarity
abstract
This paper focuses on two mechanical properties of granules, the coefficient of restitution and the
strength, and analyzes their sensitivity to granule geometric parameters. The granules were obtained
by fluid bed granulation of glass beads with an aqueous solution of PEG1500. Collisions were arranged
between granules, and for granules against two glass plates, the first of them a non-covered plate, whereas
the second was a plate covered with a thin film of PEG1500. The coefficient of restitution and the strength
were measured for the granules, the former for individual particles also. In the case of individual glass
particles the coefficient of restitution was around 0.61 for impacts on the flat glass, and 0.5 on the cov-
ered glass; for the granules, this parameter was around 0.44 for both situations and for collisions between
granules. Sphericity, lacunarity and fractal dimension of the granule projected area, as well as the gran-
ule porosity, were determined. Granules giving the highest values for strength had the largest fractal
dimension and the smallest lacunarity values regardless of their sphericity, porosity and coefficient of
restitution.
© 2009 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Fluidized bed technology is employed to achieve granulation of
particles with the net agglomeration process being defined by the
nature of the inter-particle collisions. Either size enlargement or
alternatively attrition and breakage can result from these collisions.
In addition, collisions between granules and the walls of the equip-
ment have a significant effect on the evolution of granule size [1].
To understand and predict the outcome of collisions, knowledge of
the mechanical properties of the granular material is required [2].
This work focuses on two such properties, the coefficient of resti-
tution and the granule strength. In particular, this work examines
their sensitivity to geometric parameters of the granules.
The system under analysis consists of the Würster granulation
process based on fluidized bed bottom-spray granulation. The flu-
idized granules travel up an inner tube and exit out the top into
the main chamber, fall down the annular space between the tube
and the chamber and then repeat the motion. The granules were
assembled from glass beads by addition of PEG1500 into an aqueous
solution.
Geometric characteristics, e.g. sphericity, can influence the
result of particle collisions, i.e. due to the particle shape and orien-
tation it is possible to obtain different results for particle–particle
∗
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: darioiker@gmail.com (D.I. Téllez-Medina).
and wall–particle interactions [3,4]. Another geometric character-
istic is the irregularity of particle surface which can be quantified
by means of fractal dimension (D
F
). Fractal dimension is based on
the concepts first proposed by Mandelbrot [5] to characterize nat-
ural shapes with mathematical patterns more close to reality than
those extracted from Euclidean geometry, and it has been applied to
different systems and phenomena to quantitatively describe their
morphology [6–10]. The use of fractal dimension as a shape descrip-
tor for granules has been reported by [6,10,11]. Lacunarity () is
a complementary parameter to quantify the heterogeneity in the
distribution of void spaces inside a figure or pattern [12]. Compara-
ble to sphericity, D
F
and can be determined with image analysis
software, by applying the box counting and gliding box methods,
respectively [5–14].
2. Experimental
Granules were obtained by fluidized bed wet granulation from
200 g of glass beads (Jencons-PLS, UK) with a mean diameter
equal to 268 m, and 10 g of an aqueous 60% (w/w) dissolu-
tion of polyethylene glycol (PEG) 1500 Da (Fluka, Germany). The
granulation equipment employed was a Mini-AirPro (Pro-C-epT,
Belgium) with the Würster configuration. In Table 1 are resumed
the processing conditions. The total processing time was approxi-
mately 25 min plus a drying period (1 min) to evaporate the water
remaining in the binder liquid making contact with the individual
particles.
1385-8947/$ – see front matter © 2009 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.cej.2009.11.035