Energy and Buildings 37 (2005) 49–54
Space temperature difference, cooling coil and fan—energy
and indoor air quality issues revisited
S.C. Sekhar
∗
Department of Building National University of Singapore, 4 Architecture Drive, Singapore 117566, Singapore
Received 10 March 2004; received in revised form 26 April 2004; accepted 6 May 2004
Abstract
In designing an energy-efficient air-conditioning system that also simultaneously addresses the needs of adequate ventilation and
acceptable indoor air quality, several factors begin to play an important role. Among several others, the cooling coil, the fan and the
temperature difference between the space and the supply air (commonly known as the Space T) can be considered to be crucial. For a
given space cooling load, the choice of a particular Space T has an implication on the amount of supply air required, which further has
an impact on the performance of the cooling and dehumidifying coil as well as the fan. Inherent in these implications are issues related
to energy, ventilation and indoor air quality. This paper investigates these implications and quantifies them by considering a hypothetical
building in a tropical climate and subjecting the design to several parametric variations involving different Space Ts for a given space
temperature and humidity condition. The total power requirements, comprising additional cooling, reheating and higher fan power, for
a design involving a Space T of 5
◦
C can be as high as a factor of 2.2 of the total power for a design with a Space T of 8
◦
C. The
implication of higher supply air flow rates on duct design is qualitatively discussed. For a given space cooling load and a given Space
T, the implication of increased design ventilation rates to address part-load ventilation requirements can lead to an additional installed
cooling capacity of 17.5%. Finally, emerging technologies that are aimed at addressing both energy efficiency and IAQ are discussed.
© 2004 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Cooling coil; Supply air temperature; HVAC system; Energy; Ventilation; Indoor air quality
1. Introduction
The optimal design of an air-conditioning system and its
successful implementation and operation in a building is
obviously a great challenge, especially when both energy
and indoor air quality (IAQ) issues are of equal importance.
It is, indeed, the designer’s knowledge and understand-
ing of the dynamically varying system characteristics as a
dynamic response to the inevitably varying cooling load
characteristics that will ultimately prove to be crucial in the
design of an optimal and successful system. Often, some
of the fundamental principles in psychrometrics are likely
to be either overlooked at design or accepted as limiting
constraints in current state-of-the-art technology that lead to
designs, which may be considered as the best compromise.
Among several factors concerning energy consumption and
IAQ that are intertwined in conventional design practice, it
is often economics, and particularly, the capital cost, that
become the governing criterion in the selection of a design.
∗
Tel.: +65-874-3479; fax: +65-775-5502.
E-mail address: bdgscs@nus.edu.sg (S.C. Sekhar).
In recent times, the need for a life cycle costing approach
towards the selection of air-conditioning and air-distribution
systems is strongly advocated, considering that the eco-
nomic life span of such systems are reasonably long and
are, typically, in the range of 10–15 years [1–3]. This pa-
per revisits some of the fundamental thinking in the design
considerations of two of the most important and critical
components in an air-conditioning system:
• Cooling and dehumidifying coil
• Fan
Having estimated the cooling loads in a building, the
volume flow rate of air supplied to the various zones is then
a function of the space dry bulb temperature (DBT) and
the supply air DBT. The difference in these temperatures,
called the Space T, is a critical design parameter as it has
implications in terms of both the cooling coil capacity and
its performance and the amount of supply air necessary for
handling the space cooling loads. The implication includes
both energy and IAQ and is prevalent throughout the entire
operating range of the air-conditioning system. For exam-
ple, a small Space T for a given space DBT would not
0378-7788/$ – see front matter © 2004 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.enbuild.2004.05.003