Civil Engineering and Architecture 4(2): 39-46, 2016 http://www.hrpub.org
DOI: 10.13189/cea.2016.040201
Sustainable Tourism along the Red Sea: Still Possible?
Amir Gohar
*
, G. Mathias Kondolf
Department of Landscape Architecture & Environmental Planning, University of California, USA
Copyright©2016 by authors, all rights reserved. Authors agree that this article remains permanently open access under the
terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0 International License
Abstract The Red Sea is a unique resource whose
potential remains underutilized. Since the 1980s
development for mass tourism has destroyed the northern
coastal stretches as exemplified by the city of Hurghada. A
number of initiatives have taken place in the past to protect
areas along the Red Sea (from Marsa Alam city South),
including introduction of ecotourism and coastal planning
guidelines by the Red Sea Sustainable Tourism Initiative
(RSSTI) in 2000-2004. Also, the “Livelihood and Income
From Environment (LIFE)” program in 2005-2008
supported implementing pilot projects in national parks to
demonstrate the appropriate processes. Since 2008, local
NGOs (e.g; HEPCA) initiated sustainable practices such as
Solid Waste Management and Mooring Buoys. Despite these
initiatives, the main obstacles to improved planning and
development are found to be: (i) lack of coordination within
the ministry and stakeholders, (ii) lack of contextual design
relevance to the Red Sea, and (iii) inappropriate land
subdivisions and development in environmentally vulnerable
areas. The solutions for such complex problems are
summarized below: (i) Elevate land use planning above the
ministry level, (ii) incorporate appropriate planning and
building education, (iii) mandatory use of Land use
suitability maps in the region.
Keywords Sustainable Tourism, Land Use Planning,
Red Sea, Egypt
1. Introduction
1.1. Background
The Red Sea is a unique environment with deserts rich in
history abutting a sea whose remarkable coral reefs are
among the best in the world. With its striking environment
and touristic potential, sunny climate, and short flight
distance from major population centers in Europe, the
Egyptian Red Sea coast has tremendous potential for
economic development and benefits for the nation and region.
Since this coast was opened to tourism after the Camp David
Accords of 1978, the number of hotel rooms shot up from
about 40 in 1980, to about 1890 in 1989 to about 7000 in
1999, to over 40,000 in 2009 (1). This rapid development
came with unfortunate impacts on the coast and coral reefs
(2).
Most of the coast is flanked by a fringing coral reef, which
blocks access to deep water (3). Exceptions are the mouths of
dry streams (wadis), where there are breaks in the fringing
reef and commonly embayments (marsas) that offer
anchorage and access to deep water for boats, snorkelling
opportunities along the reef edge of the embayment, and
swimming beaches along the landward shore. Thus, the best
places for tourist resorts are next to marsas, with their access
to snorkelling and open water. However, development has
been promoted (by the Tourism Development Authority) on
parcels evenly distributed along the coast; most sites are
along fringing reef, where it is impossible to swim in the sea.
This motivated some developers near Hurghada to physically
remove the reef in front of their hotels, or to fill over the reef
in attempts to create direct access to deep water; (4). While
such blatant destruction is no longer common, development
patterns along the coast are still not informed by the
underlying carrying capacity of the coastal geomorphology,
coastal waters and thus their coral reefs) have been affected
by chronic pollution and are at risk of extensive
contamination from flash floods that will scour waste dumps
in Wadis and carry chemicals, garbage, and other pollutants
out to the coral reef (5) and (6)
1.2. Objective
This paper aims to analyze exiting institutional structure
under which development occurs in order to understand the
points of deficits in the planning process. In addition,
critically review the environmental planning initiatives that
have taken place so far and understand their successes and
failures in order to inform the decision makers of future
considerations while designing or implementing such
projects. And inform private developers on best practices to
consider while working on new development along the
Egyptian Southern area of the Red Sea coast.