$EVWUDFWThis paper presents a new rotor for permanent
magnet wind generators aimed to reduce the amount of
rare-earth materials. The new rotor configuration has been
used for the design of a 10 MW PM generator for direct
drive wind turbines in order to reduce their magnet costs.
In order to prove its effectiveness, also a conventional
PMSG with surface magnets rotor is considered as reference
machine for comparison. Using the same geometry and
electrical constrains the both PMSGs are developed
following an analytical iterative procedure and afterwards
using FEA. According to the preliminary results, the new
rotor design requires significantly less magnet material
compared with the conventional rotor. Investigations done
on the 10 MW PMSG shows that with the proposed design
the magnet weight can be reduced for about 2.7 tons.
Index Terms-permanent magnet generator, new pm
rotor configuration, rare earth material reduction, 10 MW
direct drive generator.
I. INTRODUCTION
Direct drive permanent magnet generators (DD-
PMGs) are becoming increasingly important for large-
scale wind turbines as they remove the need for a gearbox
and the high maintenance costs associated with using
them. In direct-drive configuration the wind blades are
directly connected to the generator, which therefore runs
at a low speed (e. g. about 20 rpm). However, the low
speed DD-PMGs for high power applications requires
bigger machines able to produce high torque. In order to
reduce the generator weight and size, all existing large-
scale DD-PMGs use expensive rare earth magnets with
high energy density [1-5]. The required amount of
permanent magnets in various PMSG configurations
depends on the generator size, operation speed and
thermal aspects. Usually, large direct drive PM wind
generators requires huge amount of magnet material. In
literature values of 0.6t to 1t per 1MW are given [1, 6].
Considering that, the rare-earth magnet materials have
a much higher specific cost than laminated steel and
copper, in many cases, the cost of PMs is a significant
part of the total machine costs [4, 5]. Moreover, the
increase in the price of rare earths adversely affected
wind turbine manufacturers’ production costs and profit
margin. Therefore, reduction of expensive magnet
materials by wind generators is of main interests for
reducing their costs. To this topic, different substation
strategies for reducing the use of rare-earths in wind
turbines, such as, increasing the material efficiency,
substitution of rare earth in permanent magnets, or use
alternative technologies to PMSGs, have been addressed
in [7, 8]. Further, in [9] a ferrite magnet alternative design
(to the NdFeB) has been shown to be a competitive
solution on costs of energy basis. Another method to
reduce the magnet amount by PM machines without
weakening their performances is proposed recently in
[10]. Here different from the recent techniques, the
reduction in the magnet amount has been achieved by
improving the utilization of permanent magnets on the
air-gap flux density production.
In this paper, the new PM rotor with highly utilized
magnets was investigated for DD-PMGs application.
Section 2 describes briefly the new PM rotor
configuration. The analytical approach for air-gap flux
density is given in section 3. Afterwards, the machine
parameters are derived in section 4. The first rough
generator design using the analytical approach is derived
in section 5. Finally, section 6 investigates the new PM
rotor for wind power generator applications with the
focus reduction of magnet amount for the same power
compared with the common surface magnets rotors. As
exemplary generator, a 10MW DD offshore PMSG is
considered according to the specification given in [11].
II. NEW PM ROTOR DESIGN
A new PM rotor configuration that operate with the 3
rd
rotor magneto motive force (MMF) harmonic as
operating wave was proposed in [10] and is illustrated in
the following Fig. 1. The realization of this rotor type was
achieved as a combination of two different rotor
topologies, e.g. the first rotor with lateral magnets and
additional flux-barriers (FB), and a second configuration
with spoke magnets and with lateral magnet-slots as flux-
barrier (FB). Moreover, the permanent magnets of the
first and the second configuration are magnetized
oppositely. In addition to that, the both rotor
configuration produce a sub-harmonic component on the
rotor MMF, however using flux-barriers, these
component will be reduced and transformed to the
operating 3
rd
harmonic. Furthermore, by combination of
rotor 1 and 2 in one rotor core the 1
st
MMF harmonic will
be able to reduced or completely cancelled, while the 3
rd
or the working harmonic will be increased. This result on
the reduction of rare earth magnet amount required for
torque/power generation.
III. AIR-GAP FLUX DENSITY ANALYSIS
Reference [12] presents an analytical approach to
determine the no-load air-gap flux density for the PM
machines with the new rotor configuration. According to
Ampere’s circuital law, and neglecting the MMF’s drop
in stator and rotor iron portions, the radial air-gap field
PM Wind Generator with Reduced Amount of
Rare-Earth Magnet Material
G. Dajaku*, and D. Gerling**
*FEAAM GmbH, 85579-Neubiberg, Germany
**Bundeswehr University Munich, 85579-Neubiberg, Germany
978-1-7281-1356-2/19/$31.00 ©2019 IEEE