Journal of European Studies
Prisoners’ fantasies in Weimar film
The longing for a rational and just legal system
OFER ASHKENAZI
The Hebrew University, Jerusalem
Prison cells constituted a unique sphere in post-World War I
German films. Unlike most of the modern city spheres, it was a
realm in which the private and the public often merged, and in
which reality and fantasy incessantly intertwined. This article
analyses the ways in which filmmakers of the Weimar Republic
envisaged the experience within the prison, focusing on its fre-
quent association with fantasies and hallucinations. Through the
analysis of often-neglected films from the period, I argue that this
portrayal of the prison enabled Weimar filmmakers to engage
in public criticism against the conservative, inefficient and pre-
judiced institutions of law and order in Germany. Since German
laws forbade direct defamation of these institutions, filmmakers
such as Joe May, Wilhelm Dietherle and Georg C. Klaren employed
the symbolism of the prisoner’s fantasy to propagate the urgent
need for thorough reform. Thus this article suggests that Weimar
cinema, contrary to common notions, was not dominated by either
escapism or extremist, anti-liberal worldviews. Instead, the prison
films examined in this article are in fact structured as a warning
against the decline of liberal bourgeois society in the German
urban centres of the late 1920s.
Keywords: German film, liberalism, madness, prison, Weimar
Republic
Journal of European Studies 39(3): 290–304 Copyright © The Author(s), 2009.
Reprints and permissions: http://www.sagepub.co.uk/journalsPermissions.nav
jes.sagepub.com [200909] 0047-2441/10.1177/0047244109106683