- Impacts of a native and an invasive exotic shrub on flood-plain succession - 135
Journal of Vegetation Science 16: 135-142, 2005
© IAVS; Opulus Press Uppsala.
Abstract
Question: How do Coriaria arborea, an N-fixing native
shrub, and Buddleja davidii, a non-N-fixing exotic shrub,
affect N:P stoichiometry in plants and soils during early stages
of primary succession on a flood-plain?
Location: Kowhai River Valley, northeast South Island, New
Zealand.
Methods: We measured soil and foliar nutrient concentra-
tions, light levels, plant community composition and the above-
ground biomass of Coriaria and Buddleja in four successional
stages: open, young, vigorous and mature.
Results: Coriaria occurred at low density but dominated
above-ground biomass by the vigorous stage. Buddleja oc-
curred at 5.3 ± 1.0 stems/m
2
in the young stage and reached a
maximum biomass of 520-535 g.m
–2
during the young and
vigorous stages. Mineral soil N increased with above-ground
Coriaria biomass (r
2
= 0.45), but did not vary with Buddleja
biomass. In contrast, soil P increased with Buddleja biomass
(r
2
= 0.35), but not with Coriaria biomass. In early succes-
sional stages, 70-80% of the species present were exotic, but
this declined to about 15% by the mature stage. Exotic plant
species richness declined with increasing Coriaria biomass,
but no other measures of diversity varied with either Coriaria
or Buddleja biomass.
Conclusion: These results demonstrate that Buddleja domi-
nates early succession and accumulates P whereas Coriaria
dominates later succession and accumulates N. A key ecosys-
tem effect of the invasive exotic Buddleja is alteration of soil
N:P stoichiometry.
Keywords: Buddleja davidii; Coriaria arborea; Diversity;
Facilitation; N:P stoichiometry; Nutrient accumulation; Pri-
mary succession; Soil nutrient.
Nomenclature: Allan (1961) with amendments suggested by
Connor & Edgar (1987), and Webb et al. (1988).
Contrasting impacts of a native and an invasive exotic shrub
on flood-plain succession
Bellingham, Peter J.
1*
; Peltzer, Duane A.
1,2
& Walker, Lawrence R.
3
1
Landcare Research, P.O. Box 69, Lincoln 8152, New Zealand;
2
E-mail peltzerd@landcareresearch.co.nz;
3
Department of Biological Sciences, Box 454004, University of Nevada Las Vegas, 4505 Maryland Parkway,
Las Vegas, NV 89154-4004, USA; E-mail walker@unlv.nevada.edu;
*
Corresponding author; Fax +64 33252418; E-mail bellinghamp@landcareresearch.co.nz
Introduction
Plant species can modify above- and below-ground
resource availability (Wardle 2002) in ways that drive
successional species replacements (Clements 1916;
Tilman 1988). Invasive species with novel functions or
impacts on resource availability can produce novel suc-
cessional sequences (Vitousek 1990; D’Antonio et al.
1999). Woody plants with bacterial symbionts that fix N
(‘N-fixing shrubs’) often drive primary succession
through N-accretion and enhanced soil development
(Van Cleve et al. 1971; Walker 1993; Chapin et al.
1994). However, N-fixation demands high levels of P
that may, like N, be in low supply in primary succession
(Vitousek 1999; Uliassi & Ruess 2002). Although P can
limit primary productivity over the long term (Walker &
Syers 1976; Richardson et al. 2004), the implications of
alterations of N:P stoichiometry by plants during pri-
mary succession are not known.
Many plant species have the ability to accumulate N,
P or other elements well beyond the concentrations
found in other plants or in the soil (Epstein 1972; Grime
2001). To our knowledge, impacts of co-occurring N
and P accumulators have not been examined in studies
of primary succession. New combinations of species
can alter successional and ecosystem dynamics in novel
ways that need examination. We studied a native N-
fixing shrub and an invasive shrub that does not fix N
but accumulates both N and P in a New Zealand flood-
plain system. We asked the following questions: what
were the relative impacts of the two shrub species on (1)
species richness and composition; (2) soil nutrient avail-
ability and N:P stoichiometry and (3) how did the two
species interact during early succession?