Proceedings of the 2019 5
th
International Conference on Advances in Electrical Engineering (ICAEE),
26-28 September, Dhaka, Bangladesh.
978-17281-4934-9/19/$31.00©2019 IEEE
Study of frequency variant tan delta diagnosis for
MV cables insulation status assessment
Md Zulfiker Heider
Electrical Engineering Department
King Saud University
Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
heidereee@gmail.com
Mohammad Mominur Rahman
Department of Electrical & Electronic
Engineering
Ahsanullah University of Science &
Technology
Dhaka, Bangladesh.
momin128@gmail.com
A. A. Al-Arainy
Electrical Engineering Department
King Saud University
Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
aarainy@ksu.edu.sa
Abstract— There is no doubt that the condition or status
assessment of the insulation of any medium voltage (MV) cable
is essential for the secure and reliable operation of electrical
networks. It is reputed that the aging and degradation of the
insulation causes severe damage to any MV equipment.
Therefore, if these degradations of the insulation can be
detected/diagnosed earlier, then corrective action can be
initiated. Tan Delta (tan δ) or loss tangent is widely used as a
diagnostic method for determining the quality of the insulation
in cables.
At low-frequency measurements of tan δ (loss tangent) seem
to yield much information about the state of the insulation.
Similarly, in some cases frequency higher than 50 Hz or 60 Hz
provides useful information about insulation status of MV
cables. That is why the values of tan δ are not strictly constant
and but depend on various factors such as frequency,
temperature, humidity, and voltage. Thus it is important to
understand such relationships by experimental investigations.
In this study measurement of tan δ (TD) at different
frequencies (such as 0.01 Hz, 0.1 Hz, 50 Hz, 100 Hz to 400 Hz,
etc.) for MV cables will be evaluated. All measurements are
taken under standard environmental conditions for new,
service old and artificially laboratory aged samples. Finally,
the obtained values of tan δ from the measurements will be
analyzed in order to find out if there is any correlation between
tan δ and frequencies (f) with the insulation condition/status
under laboratory environment.
Keywords—MV cables, Loss tangent, Insulation degradation.
I. INTRODUCTION
The insulation of any high voltage equipment is usually
made up of different components. These components are
selected to withstand different electrical, mechanical,
thermal, and environmental stresses. In the past, functional
evaluation of insulation was based primarily on thermal
stresses. However, with many types of equipment, other
aging stresses or factors, such as mechanical, electrical, and
environmental may also be dominant and could significantly
influence the service life of the insulation [1-6].
Effective and reliable insulation is essential for the
correct and safe operation of any electrical equipment. In
MV systems, protection testing is considerably increasingly
significant, on the grounds that the protection is frequently
under more prominent electrical pressure. Therefore,
failures are likely to be costlier and potentially more
dangerous in such systems compare to low voltage systems.
Recently several insulation testing techniques such as
RVM (Recovery Voltage Method), PDC (Polarization and
Depolarization Currents) and tan delta (tan δ) method. have
been developed. Every method has some advantages and
disadvantages. Similarly, there are many advantages of tan
δ method for insulation condition assessment. But the most
important thing is ease of use of tan delta diagnostic system
in field levels. [9].
Several investigations have been made to find out the
effect of voltage, frequency, and temperatures in tan δ (TD)
measurements. Yakun et al. [1] showed the influence of the
temperature and frequency on leakage current of XLPE
cable. He found the cable conductivity is high at low
frequency and at high temperature. At high frequency, cable
conductivity did not affect that much with the increase of
temperature in XLPE cable.
Kocatepe et al. [2] mentioned the dissipation factor and
dielectric losses increase with the increase of voltage. But
the variation of tan δ for certain smaller increases i.e. for 2-
4 kV deviation at the beginning is not that much. But when
the voltage increases to 8kV and higher, then tan values
increase significantly. And these measurements were taken
at 50 Hz frequency.
Chandan Kumar Chakrabarty et al.[3] developed a high-
frequency tan delta testing method for underground cable.
Then they tested some good cables, contaminated cables and
void cables at 50 Hz and 1 kHz. They showed a correlation
between tan delta with 50 Hz and 1 kHz using normalization
from the obtained tan delta values of their experiments.
Belle Valerie Wong et al.[7] investigated VLF tan
delta(TD) and PD measurement in MV cables. They found
that VLF TD (tan δ) measurement is useful and reflects the
overall condition of the cable as well as to indicate the
presence of wet joints and water tree aging.
J. C. Hernández-Mejía et al. [6] did experiment to find
out the correlation between tan δ Diagnostic Measurements
and Breakdown Performance at VLF for MV XLPE Cables.
They used 0.1 Hz and 60 Hz frequency test voltages for
their findings. They successfully presented the co-relation
with tan delta and breakdown.