*
Corresponding author: hasna.louahlia@unicaen.fr
Comparison of the thermal performance between conventional
and cob building
Kaoutar Zeghari
1
, Hasna Louahlia
1,*
, Malo Leguern
2
, Mohamed Boutouil
2
, Hamid Gualous
1
, Michael Marion
1
, Pierre
Schaetzel
1
, Steeve Goodhew
3
and François Streif
4
1
Normandy University, LUSAC-Unicaen, Site universitaire Bellevue, 50000 Saint Lô, France
2
ESITC Caen, Campus 2, 14610 Epron, France
3
Plymouth University, Drake Circus, Plymouth PL4 8AA, UK
4
Cotentin and Bessin marshlands regional national park, France
Abstract. The appliance of sustainable development approach in building has urged construction
industry to adopt proper measurements to protect environment and reduce residential building
energy consumption and CO2 emissions. Thus, an increasing interest in alternative building
materials has developed including the use of bio-based materials such as cob which is studied
in this paper. In the previous work, many experimental and numerical studies have been carried
out to characterize thermal behaviour of earth buildings, reduce its thermal conductivity and
water content. In this paper, an experimental study is carried out to determine the thermal
properties and energy performance of cob building. Cob samples within different soil and fiber
contents are studied using an experimental set up instrumented with flux meters and micro-
thermocouples in order to evaluate the local heat flux and thermal conductivity during stationary
regime. The results are analysed and compared to deduce the performant mixes in terms of
thermal behaviour while respecting the French thermal regulation. A static thermal simulation
based on RT 2012 calculation method (the official French calculation method for the energy
performance of new residential and commercial buildings according to France thermal
regulation) is used to compare energy performance between conventional and cob building
using the French climate data base .
1 Introduction
Since the last past years, contemporaneous concerns about
energy consumption and greenhouse gas emissions have
rapidly immerged intriguing environmentalists,
researchers and public consciousness. There has been an
important influence of energy consumption on the
economic progress leading to raise awareness about
effective resources monitoring [1].
According to the last report “International Energy
Outlook 2013”of the Energy Information Administration
(EIA, 2013) the world energy consumption will rise to
56% between 2010 and 2040.Yet, Built environment is a
substantial consumer of energy, according to Saidur R et
al. [2] the residential energy consumption reached 31% of
the world energy in 2009. In the USA, primary energy
consumption in the residential sector is estimated around
54% of consumption in the building sector, while in the
EU it has increased by around 1%/year since 1990
(Environment and Energy Management Agency, 2012).
As a response to the increasing energy consumption in
buildings, many policies and means have been adopted in
order to promote energy efficiency and sustainable
buildings [3]. Therefore, an increasing interest in
alternative building materials such as bio-based materials
particularly earth has arisen because of the extensive
environmental problems such as climate change and the
impoverishment of resources combined with the rapid
technological advancement within the building sector.
Earth is often acknowledged as sustainable building
material, based on its low embodied energy [4]. As
described by Hamed et al [5], there are different types of
earth buildings such as: Rammed earth buildings, Adobe,
Wattle and Daub, Poured earth and cob that is studied in
this paper.
Thus, Cob which is defined as a mixture of earth and
fibers that is then mixed with water has been used long-
time ago thanks to its suitable construction properties. It
has the advantage of fulfilling all strength and service
ability requirements for thermal building performance.
Earth construction materials are not renewable materials
but can be reused while keeping their thermal properties
within low thermal resistance. Many authors [6] have
shown that the thermal conductivity in earth building can
vary from 0.47 to 1 W/m°C according to straw content,
density and water content. Many experimental and
numerical studies have been carried out to characterize
thermal behavior of earth buildings. Mansour et al. [7]
demonstrated the use of optimal bulk density of 1750
kg.m
-3
makes possible to reach the objective of reducing
thermal conductivity of the CEB (compressed earth
blocks) to 0.75W m
-1
K
-1
. Meukam et al. [8] have carried
out an experimental study on the thermal properties of
bricks made from lateritic soil. The obtained results
present a rapid increase for low water content and a
maximum diffusivity for a water content of 14% for
laterite and 8% for laterite with addition of natural
pozzolan or sawdust. Lucile Soudani, Monika Woloszyn
et al [9] investigated thermal performance about a real
case study. The house studied is located in Saint-Antoine
l’Abbaye, in Isère, South-Eastern France. The house
affords a good comfort in summer within regards to
stability and level of temperatures. Besides, it provides a
good energy performance in winter because temperature
gets comfortable with a very low heating load. Results
,0 (201 Web of Conferences https://doi.org/10.1051/e3sconf/2019111030 9)
201
E3S 111
CLIMA 9
300 03 3
© The Authors, published by EDP Sciences. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).