Theoria, Issue 163, Vol. 67, No. 2 (June 2020): 52-81 © Berghahn Books
doi:10.3167/th.2020.6716303•ISSN0040-5817(Print)•ISSN1558-5816(Online)
Hegemony, Crisis and
Bonapartism in Italy,
Spain and France
Francesco Maria Scanni and
Francesco Compolongo
Abstract: The 2008 crisis and economic transformations (globalisation
and financialisation) fuelled significant political phenomena, such as a
deep distrust of politics, electoral volatility and the decline of bipolarity
and/or bipartisanship in the face of growing outsider party affirmation.
In this context, the dialectical model of the Gramscian ‘social totality’
provides an analytical tool capable of analysing those ‘transition’ phases
characterised by a fracturing ‘dominant historical bloc’, in itself a pre-
cursor to an organic crisis of traditional political parties’ separation of
social classes.
Keywords: Bonapartism, crisis, Gramsci, hegemony, new parties, pas-
sive revolution
Gramscian thought is deeply embedded in the historical context and
socio-economic reality of its time, while also being easily transposed
or translated into political terms, as demonstrated by its interpreta-
tion of Marxism in terms of a ‘philosophy of praxis’. It can therefore
be rediscovered and reinterpreted in light of changes in society and
in development models, allowing us to decipher the intricate pro-
cesses of our times and the social and political responses enacted in
turn. Gramscian theory can therefore become a useful method for
comprehending and ‘re-ordering’ a reality that often appears dif-
ficult to grasp in its complexity. This article uses the lens of Grams-
cian theory to interrogate the effects of the 2008 economic crisis
(and its associated crises of traditional political models, praxes and
interpretative schema) on the political system. Traditional subjects,