The Development of
Symbolic Coordination:
Representation of Imagined Objects,
Executive Function, and Theory of Mind
Anthony Steven Dick, Willis F. Overton,
and Stacie L. Kovacs
Temple University
Children’s developing competence with symbolic representations was assessed in 3
studies. Study 1 examined the hypothesis that the production of imaginary symbolic
objects in pantomime requires the simultaneous coordination of the dual representa-
tions of a dynamic action and a symbolic object. We explored this coordination of
symbolic representations in 3- to 5-year-olds with a modified action pantomime task
that employed both a “dynamic action + object” condition and a “hold + object” con-
dition. Consistent with earlier research, production of imaginary symbolic objects
rather than body-part-as-objects increased with age, although, even at age 5, children
did not perform at adult levels. As hypothesized, children produced fewer
body-part-as-object anchors when they were simply asked to hold an object, rather
than perform a dynamic action with the object. Study 2 repeated the conditions of
Study 1 and examined these conditions in relation to performance on the Dimen-
sional Change Card Sort (DCCS) task. This study replicated the developmental find-
ings of the earlier study and indicated a modest relation between pantomime and the
DCCS, which disappeared with age partialled out. Study 3 examined the action pan-
tomime task in relation to the DCCS, false belief, and appearance–reality with 3- to
5-year-olds. Though performance on the DCCS was related to theory of mind, pro-
duction of imaginary symbolic objects in pantomime was not strongly related to the-
ory of mind or the DCCS. Results are discussed in terms of children’s developing re-
flective competence in coordinating symbolic representations.
JOURNAL OF COGNITION AND DEVELOPMENT, 6(1), 133–161
Copyright © 2005, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc.
Requests for reprints should be sent to Willis F. Overton, Temple University Department of Psy-
chology, Room 656 Weiss Hall 1701 N. 13th St. Philadelphia, PA 19122–6085. E-mail: overton@tem-
ple.edu