Vol.:(0123456789) 1 3
Clean Technologies and Environmental Policy
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10098-020-01880-5
ORIGINAL PAPER
Environmental performance assessment of manufacturing sectors
Onder Belgin
1
· Dursun Balkan
1
Received: 13 December 2019 / Accepted: 3 June 2020
© Springer-Verlag GmbH Germany, part of Springer Nature 2020
Abstract
This study addresses to rank the environmental performance of manufacturing sectors using Preference Ranking Organization
Method for Enrichment Evaluation (PROMETHEE) method which is a widely used multi-criteria decision making method
for environmental management. The study focuses on 24 manufacturing sectors and 5 criteria—water usage, environmental
expenditure, environmental employment, waste recover and waste density—to rank the environmental performance of the
manufacturing sectors. Rankings of the manufacturing sectors are made using PROMETHEE II, which is a developed version
of PROMETHEE, with three scenarios (base scenario, environmental scenario, economic scenario) obtained by diferent
weightings of the criteria. In the analysis stage, manufacturing sectors are ranked and then environmental performance of the
sectors is compared in terms of four technology levels (low technology, medium–low technology, medium–high technology
and high technology) proposed by OECD. According to the results, manufacture of tobacco products is the best performing
sector and manufacture of chemicals and chemical products is the worst performing sector in each scenario. Furthermore,
high-technology and medium–high-technology sectors have better environmental performance than medium–low-technology
and low-technology sectors in each scenario. After that, Geometrical Analysis for Interactive Aid planes were used to under-
stand the weak and strong points of the manufacturing sectors. Better performing sectors are good at water usage, waste
recover and waste density criteria, but bad at environmental expenditure and environmental employment criteria. This study
closes the gap as the frst study on the environmental performance of Turkish manufacturing sectors using a multi-criteria
decision making method, and we hope that this study will be benefcial for the researchers in this area.
Graphic abstract
Water Usage
Environmental
Expenditure
Environmental
Employment
Waste
recover
Waste
density
Turkish Manufacturing Sectors (NACE Rev.2)
PROMETHEE II
RANKING BASED
ON LEVEL OF
TECHNOLOGY
LEVELS
GENERAL
RANKING
DATA
METHODOLGY
RESULTS
Keywords Environmental performance · Multi-criteria decision making · Manufacturing sectors · Performance
measurement · PROMETHEE · GAIA plane
* Onder Belgin
onderbelgin@gmail.com
Extended author information available on the last page of the article