Molecular and morphological data place Blarneya in
Tylophoron (Arthoniaceae)
Damien ERTZ, Frank BUNGARTZ, Paul DIEDERICH and
Leif TIBELL
Abstract: Based on morphological, anatomical, chemical, ecological and molecular evidence, Blar-
neya is synonymized here with Tylophoron. The molecular phylogeny derived from sequences obtained
from sporodochia of Blarneya places this genus, described to accommodate an anamorphic lichen with
white cushion-shaped sporodochia, within Tylophoron. This conclusion is further supported by the
discovery of Tylophoron-type ascomata emerging directly from thalli with Blarneya-type sporodochia
and producing identical hyaline conidia. In one specimen pycnidia were also observed. This represents
a surprising variety of morphologically different conidiomata. A different anamorphic type was
previously reported from Tylophoron, and this is confirmed here by molecular analysis for T. modera-
tum: besides thalli with ascomata this species has anamorphic thalli with an irregularly delimited brown
sporodochial felt and brown conidia. Ascomata are not known from these entirely anamorphic thalli,
whereas they do occur infrequently in Tylophoron species with Blarneya-type sporodochia. A key to all
currently accepted species of Tylophoron is provided. In addition to the corticolous Tylophoron
hibernicum, confined to humid forests, two saxicolous species with Blarneya-type sporodochia are
described here as new: T. galapagoense, known only from Galapagos, differs from T. hibernicum by a
thicker, more compact, beige rather than white, more strongly C+ red thallus, growing below sheltered
rock overhangs in dry forests; T. stalactiticum has a C- thallus with stipitate, white, C+ red sporodo-
chia; the species is known only from a single locality in Tenerife, on a large slope with volcanic
boulders.
Introduction
The genus Blarneya was described by
Hawksworth et al. (1979) for a sterile, corti-
colous lichen with a pinkish white thallus and
conspicuous white sporodochia. The thalli
were considered to be initially lichenicolous
on different species of Roccellaceae and on
Belonia caudata, eventually becoming autono-
mous after killing the host mycobiont and
taking over its photobiont (Trentepohlia).
The species was described from Ireland
and later discovered in SW England and
Wales, the Western Pyrenees (France and
Spain) and Macaronesia (Canary Islands
and Madeira) (Etayo 1989, 1992, 1998;
Chambers & Purvis 2009).
Recent field work by the authors has led
to the discovery of additional localities of
Blarneya in the Pyrenees, the Canary Islands,
continental Africa (Democratic Republic of
Congo), the USA (Florida and Hawaiian
Islands) and the Galapagos Islands
(Ecuador). Several saxicolous populations
were discovered, differing slightly from the
corticolous ones, suggesting that more than
one species might be involved, implying that
Blarneya could no longer be accepted as a
monotypic genus. Among the material exam-
ined, we also encountered specimens that
were apparently fertile with Tylophoron-like
ascomata. This observation led us to wonder
if the sporodochial thalli called Blarneya
might be an anamorph of Tylophoron, or if
these specimens were just sterile Blarneya
overgrowing fertile thalli of Tylophoron. The
genus Tylophoron has recently been shown to
D. Ertz: National Botanic Garden, Department
Bryophytes-Thallophytes (BT), Domein van Bouchout,
B-1860 Meise, Belgium. Email: damien.ertz@br.fgov.be
F. Bungartz: Charles Darwin Foundation, Puerto
Ayora, Santa Cruz Island, Galapagos; mailing address:
Av. 6 de Diciembre N 36-109 y Pasaje California, caja
postal 17-01-3891, Quito, Ecuador.
P. Diederich: Musée national d’histoire naturelle, 25 rue
Munster, L-2160 Luxembourg, Luxembourg.
L. Tibell: Department of Systematic Botany, Evolution-
ary Biology Centre, Uppsala University, Norbyvägen
18 D, SE-752 36 Uppsala, Sweden.
The Lichenologist 43(4): 345–356 (2011) © British Lichen Society, 2011
doi:10.1017/S002428291100020X