Corporate governance and internal audit:
an institutional theory perspective
Christina Vadasi, Michalis Bekiaris and Andreas Andrikopoulos
Abstract
Purpose – This paper aims to explore internal audit effectiveness through its contribution to corporate
governance. Namely, the authors attempt to investigate the impact of internal audit professionalization on
internal audit’s contribution to corporate governance.
Design/methodology/approach – Using a research framework informed by institutional theory, the
authors predict that internal audit’s contribution to corporate governance is associated with factors
related to internal audit professionalization. To investigate the arguments, the authors combine data from
a survey of 49 listed companies in the Athens Stock Exchange with publicly available information from
annual reports.
Findings – Empirical results indicate that internal audit professionalization affects internal audit
effectiveness, as internal audit’s contribution to corporate governance is improved for organizations
where internal audit function complies with internal auditing standards and internal auditors hold
professional certifications. The findings also suggest that internal audit’s contribution to corporate
governance is shaped by some company-specific characteristics, namely, CEO duality and audit
committee quality.
Practical implications – The results have implications for internal auditors who wish to increase the
efficiency of their work, corporate governance mechanisms such as the board of directors and the audit
committee, which can use the findings of this study to better respond to their responsibilities concerning
internal audit and regulators who can also benefit to strengthen areas with substantial impact on internal
audit’s contribution to corporate governance.
Originality/value – This paper contributes to the academic discussion on the role of internal audit in
corporate governance and complements the work of other researchers in the field of internal audit
professionalization. This study tries to fill a gap in the literature on the effect of internal audit
professionalization elements on internal audit’s contribution to corporate governance.
Keywords Greece, Professionalization, Internal auditing, Institutional theory, Corporate Governance,
Institute of Internal Auditors, Internal audit
Paper type Research paper
1. Introduction
Internal audit (IA) is a fundamental part of corporate governance (CG), as it is one out of
four key players of CG along with the audit committee, external audit and management
(Gramling et al., 2004;(Goodwin-Steward and Kent, 2006). IA’s importance in corporate
governance relies on its role as the only internal monitoring mechanism that operates on a
daily basis (Prawitt et al., 2009; Soh and Martinov-Bennie, 2011). Nevertheless, prior
research on IA effectiveness and its association with CG has been rather limited (Sarens,
2009; Mihret and Grant, 2017; Lenz et al., 2018). Our objective is to explore the effect of
internal audit function (IAF) on IA effectiveness through the lens of institutional theory, which
has been attracting increasing attention in the IA literature (Al-Twaijry et al., 2003; Arena
et al., 2006; Arena and Azzone,2007; Mihret et al.,2010). Namely, we use normative
isomorphism (one of three types of isomorphism in institutional theory) to assess the effect
of IA professionalization on IA’s contribution to CG. The guidance of the Institute of Internal
Christina Vadasi,
Michalis Bekiaris and
Andreas Andrikopoulos all
are based at Department of
Business Administration,
University of the Aegean,
Chios, Greece.
Received 19 July 2019
Revised 18 September 2019
20 September 2019
Accepted 22 September 2019
DOI 10.1108/CG-07-2019-0215 © Emerald Publishing Limited, ISSN 1472-0701
j
CORPORATE GOVERNANCE
j