Hydrogel-based Engineered Skeletal Muscle
Grafts Normalize Heart Function Early After
Myocardial Infarction
*Marie-Noëlle Giraud, *Erick Ayuni, †Stéphane Cook, ‡Matthias Siepe, *Thierry P. Carrel,
and *Hendrik T. Tevaearai
*Department of Cardiovascular Surgery, Inselspital; †Department of Cardiology, Inselspital, Berne, Switzerland; and
‡Department for Cardiovascular Surgery, University Medical Center, Freiburg, Germany
Abstract: Tissue engineering represents an attractive
approach for the treatment of congestive heart failure.The
influence of the differentiation of myogenic graft for func-
tional recovery is not defined. We engineered a biodegrad-
able skeletal muscle graft (ESMG) tissue and investigated
its functional effect after implantation on the epicardium of
an infarcted heart segment. ESMGs were synthesized by
mixing collagen (2 mg/mL), Matrigel (2 mg/mL), and rat
skeletal muscle cells (10
6
). Qualitative and quantitative
aspects of ESMGs were optimized. Two weeks following
coronary ligation, the animals were randomized in three
groups: ESMG glued to the epicardial surface with fibrin
(ESMG, n = 7), fibrin alone (fibrin, n = 5), or sham opera-
tion (sham, n = 4). Echocardiography, histology, and immu-
nostaining were performed 4 weeks later. A cohesive
three-dimensional tissular structure formed in vitro within
1 week. Myoblasts differentiated into randomly oriented
myotubes. Four weeks postimplantation, ESMGs were vas-
cularized and invaded by granulation tissue. Mean frac-
tional shortening (FS) was, however, significantly increased
in the ESMG group as compared with preimplantation
values (42 6 vs. 33 5%, P < 0.05) and reached the
values of controlled noninfarcted animals (control, n = 5;
45 3%; not significant). Pre- and postimplantation FS did
not change over these 4 weeks in the sham group and the
fibrin-treated animals. This study showed that it is possible
to improve systolic heart function following myocardial
infarction through implantation of differentiated muscle
fibers seeded on a gel-type scaffold despite a low rate of
survival. Key Words: Tissue engineering—Myocardial
infarction—Cell therapy—Myoblasts.
Due to limited capacity for self-repair or regenera-
tion, the myocardial tissue represents a challenging
target for regenerative medicine. One of the most
recent strategies is to provide viable cells to the
damaged area of the heart in order to promote
neovascularization and myogenesis that may lead to
functional improvement. Cell and engineered tissue
therapies have been investigated for the past decade
(1). However, beneficial effects on heart function and
regeneration, observed after cell therapy in animal
models, were not always followed by convincing clini-
cal outcomes (2). The modest or absent improvement
of heart function may be the result of poor cell speci-
ficity and quality as well as technical pitfalls during
implantation. Important questions such as the
mechanism of action, the optimal cell type, delivery
mode, and time of implantation remain major issues
that have to be experimentally investigated.
The hypothesis that increased number of survival
cells would increase the beneficial effect of cell
therapy has led to the search for different cell deliv-
ery strategies (3). The remodeling process of the
injured myocardium includes immunologic and
inflammatory reactions, which represent hostile con-
ditions for the integration and differentiation of
embedded cells. In this respect, the implantation of
an engineered muscle graft may provide a better
microenvironment for cell engraftment as it provides
a biominetic extracellular matrix. In addition, it
allows in vitro preconditioning with the control of
cell survival and differentiation as well as the
doi:10.1111/j.1525-1594.2008.00595.x
Received September 2007; revised November 2007.
Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr. Marie-
Noëlle Giraud, Department of Cardiovascular Surgery, Murten-
strasse 35 MEM C812, CH-3010 Berne, Switzerland. E-mail:
giraud@dkf.unibe.ch
Artificial Organs
32(9):692–700, Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
© 2008, Copyright the Authors
Journal compilation © 2008, International Center for Artificial Organs and Transplantation and Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
692