International Journal of Scientific Research and Engineering Development-– Volume 3 Issue 3, May – June 2020
Available at www.ijsred.com
ISSN : 2581-7175 ©IJSRED: All Rights are Reserved Page 1388
Analysis of Accepted Claims for Extension of Time
and Additional Cost in Water Building Projects
in Banten Province
Asep Rachmatullah*, Sarwono Hardjomuljadi**
*(Master of Civil Engineering, Mercu Buana University, Jakarta, Indonesia
Email: seprach@yahoo.co.id)
** (Master of Civil Engineering, Mercu Buana University, Jakarta, Indonesia
Email: sarwonohm2@gmail.com)
----------------------------------------************************----------------------------------
Abstract:
Claims in water building projects are problems that can lead the contractors to request for extension of time and additional cost to
employer. Therefore, a research is required to explain ranking factor that causes project delay and ends up in construction claims for extension
of time and additional cost, so that the employer can approve. Research data is obtained by using interview and opinion survey to respondents
through distribution of questionnaire among competent stakeholders. The research method used for data processing is descriptive statistical
method in which the validity and reliability test are done using SPSS 24. KMO Measure of Sampling is used for comparing the range between
correlation coefficient and partial correlation coefficient. The Principal Components Analysis method is used for factors extraction. The
collective of respondents’ opinion data tabulation, and analysis result in the ranking of factors in project delay. The top factors are those that
cause the claims for extension of time and additional cost are accepted by the employer. The ranking becomes consideration for employers to
take the next steps in determining attitude toward the extension of time and additional cost claims. Among 24 incidents or events that cause
project delay, the top 5 rankings are; 1) absence of contractor’s work performance progress evaluation, 2) design change, 3) low bid price ratio,
4) inconsistence of payment term with the contract, and 5) late drawings submission. Those five causative factors, based on the analysis result,
can represent this whole research results. Therefore, the contractors’ claims for extension of time and additional cost caused by any of those
five factors, are supposedly accepted by the employer.
Keywords — Claims, Extension of Time, Additional Cost, Water Building, Principal Components Analysis.
----------------------------------------************************----------------------------------
I. INTRODUCTION
Construction execution is an action to build designed
construction. A construction work can be evaluated as good or
bad based on the resulting cost, quality, and time. Project
performance is a way to determine how a project works by
comparing actual work result with how the project is planned
in the contract that has been agreed between the employer and
the service provider or contractor. Construction project
performance is highly affected by risk factors that attached in
every construction project stage. Risk factors are uncertainties.
However, in the field, there happens to be numbers of problem
that cause disputes between contractor and employer, mainly in
water building projects under the scope of Banten Province
Government.
The claims for extension of time and additional cost is one
of the demands from contractor that naturally cannot always be
granted by the employer, and as the result, the employer
experiences difficulties in taking technical decisions, even
though they have been accompanied by supervising consultant.
Based on the explanation above, it is required to formulate
the problems of factors that cause project delay and the
dominant causative factors that are not the contractor’s doing.
This research uses two types of data, primary and secondary.
Primary data is obtained from respondents’ questionnaire
answers, while secondary data is used directly from the source
without being processed. The data can be literal study such as
books, journals, papers, work order letter, or previous studies,
The respondents for this study include Heads of Work Unit,
Commitment-making Official, and Technical Executive
Officer of the Activity from the user. Then, planning consultant,
supervising consultant, and executing contractor from the
service provider of projects in Banten Province.
The independent variables of this study are events that cause
project delay that can become the base to propose claims for
extension of time and additional cost. Meanwhile, the
dependent variables are decision that will be made by the
employer based on the result of the quality and ranking of
respondents’ opinion toward the independent variables.
The result of respondents’ opinion data collecting, tabulation,
and analysis, results in ranking of causative factor of project
RESEARCH ARTICLE OPEN ACCESS