Research Reports in Belizean Archaeology, Vol. 17, 2020, pp. 341-352.
Copyright © 2020 by the Institute of Archaeology, NICH, Belize.
28 A NEIGHBOURLY DAY IN THE BEAUTYWOOD? EXPLORATORY
SPATIAL ANALYSIS OF SETTLEMENT PATTERNS AT EL PILAR
Sherman Horn III, Anabel Ford, Paulino Morales
Ongoing Lidar ground-truthing operations have produced full coverage survey maps for approximately 12 km
2
of the El Pilar
Archaeological Reserve, revealing a complex settlement mosaic of residential units, monumental groups, landscape modification
features, and apparently vacant terrain. Visual inspection of the master map suggests patterns of settlement and land use,
reflecting a series of choices by members of the ancient community at El Pilar. Residential settlement generally conforms to
favorable topography, but the distribution of smaller monumental groups, and the apparent concentrations of domestic structures
on other types of terrain suggest social factors played a role in determining settlement location. This paper presents exploratory
spatial analyses of settlement patterns at El Pilar. We examine the distribution of residential and monumental groups across the
site to search for socially meaningful spatial divisions, such as neighborhoods. Our analyses include information on labor
invested in residential groups to examine potential wealth inequalities in local settlement clusters – possible neighborhoods –
and to explore how people of different social statuses populated the landscape at El Pilar.
Introduction
The second decade of the 21
st
-Century
witnessed a revival of urban organization studies
among archaeologists, with renewed attention
placed on social units intermediate in scale
between households and the settlements they
comprised (e.g., Arnauld et al., eds. 2012;
Hutson 2016; Pacifico and Truex, eds. 2019;
Smith 2010). These settlement divisions –
whether categorized as neighborhoods, formed
by “bottom-up” processes of residential
nucleation, or districts, established by “top-
down” directives from political authorities
(Smith 2010) – provided settings for the most
intensive interactions in complex societies with
large urban centers. Regular, face-to-face
interactions characterized daily life in ancient
urban settings and created the social networks
that bound individuals into communities, and
recognizing intermediate-scale units has
increasingly become an important focus in
settlement archaeology.
This paper presents exploratory spatial
analyses of survey data from El Pilar, a major
Maya center straddling the Belize/Guatemala
frontier, to investigate settlement patterns. We
examine the relationships among monumental
and residential structures to evaluate hypotheses
of settlement preference and wealth inequality,
and we explore distributions of mapped
residential units to search for settlement clusters
that may represent neighborhoods (Smith 2011).
The distribution of public architecture provides
an additional avenue to investigate potential
partitioning of the landscape by those in power
at El Pilar. After briefly reviewing previous
research that provides the methodological
foundations for our study, we discuss the
application of three spatial analysis techniques –
average nearest neighbor analysis, kernel density
mapping, and correlation analysis between site
attributes and Euclidean distance – to the El
Pilar dataset and interpret the results. Survey at
El Pilar is ongoing, and the mapping of
additional residential and monumental groups
will undoubtedly affect our understanding of
spatial clustering in future seasons. The results
presented here therefore represent the first steps
in an evolving analysis of settlement patterns at
El Pilar, although their utility in generating data
for more detailed hypotheses and sophisticated
tests is clear.
Identifying Maya Neighborhoods – Some
Issues and Approaches
The recognition and study of
neighborhoods in ancient Mesoamerican cities
has a relatively long history, although most of
this work, until recently, has been done outside
the Maya Lowlands. Neighborhoods comprising
foreign ethnic enclaves and craft producers at
the densely occupied Central Mexican city
Teotihuacan, for example, have been a
significant focus of research since the 1970s
(Millon 1973; see Manzilla 2012, Smith 2010
for recent reviews). The clear spatial
demarcation of residential units in grid-aligned
Teotihuacan, and a long history of excavation,