584 Vol. 43, No. 4 Biol. Pharm. Bull. 43, 584–595 (2020)
© 2020 The Pharmaceutical Society of Japan
Lipid Nanoparticles for Cell-Specific in Vivo Targeted Delivery
of Nucleic Acids
Ikramy A. Khalil,
a,b
Mahmoud A. Younis,
a,b
Seigo Kimura,
a
and Hideyoshi Harashima*
,a
a
Faculty of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Hokkaido University; Kita 12, Nish -6, Kita-ku, Sapporo
060–0812, Japan: and
b
Faculty of Pharmacy, Assiut University; Assiut 71526, Egypt.
Received September 2, 2019
The last few years have witnessed a great advance in the development of nonviral systems for in vivo
targeted delivery of nucleic acids. Lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) are the most promising carriers for producing
clinically approved products in the future. Compared with other systems used for nonviral gene delivery,
LNPs provide several advantages including higher stability, low toxicity, and greater efficiency. Additionally,
systems based on LNPs can be modified with ligands and devices for controlled biodistribution and inter-
nalization into specific cells. Efforts are ongoing to improve the efficiency of lipid-based gene vectors. These
efforts depend on the appropriate design of nanocarriers as well as the development of new lipids with im-
proved gene delivery ability. Several ionizable lipids have recently been developed and have shown dramati-
cally improved efficiency. However, enhancing the ability of nanocarriers to target specific cells in the body
remains the most difficult challenge. Systemically administered LNPs can access organs in which the capil-
laries are characterized by the presence of fenestrations, such as the liver and spleen. The liver has received
the most attention to date, although targeted delivery to the spleen has recently emerged as a promising tool
for modulating the immune system. In this review, we discuss recent advances in the use of LNPs for cell-
specific targeted delivery of nucleic acids. We focus mainly on targeting liver hepatocytes and spleen immune
cells as excellent targets for gene therapy. We also discuss the potential of endothelial cells as an alternate
approach for targeting organs with a continuous endothelium.
Key words gene delivery; targeting; lipid nanoparticle; liver; spleen; endothelium
1. INTRODUCTION
Gene therapy is defined as the use of different nucleic
acids to express, edit, or silence specific genes in cells for
obtaining specific therapeutic effects. The first nucleic acid
sequences used in gene therapy were in the form of plasmid
DNA (pDNA). More recently, RNA-based drugs have been in-
troduced such as small interfering RNA (siRNA) and mRNA.
Despite the great promise of gene therapy as a tool for treat-
ing various currently incurable genetic as well as acquired
diseases, it faces several difficulties such as the toxicity of
viral vectors used in delivery of nucleic acids and the inef-
ficiency of nonviral or synthetic vectors designed to replace
the viral ones.
1–3)
The inefficiency of nonviral systems could
be explained by the lack of efficient delivery systems that suf-
ficiently protect nucleic acids and deliver them in sufficient
doses to their target sites, usually inside cells.
2,4)
However,
the last few years have witnessed a great advance in the de-
velopment of nonviral systems for in vivo targeted delivery of
genes to different organs, particularly the liver. This advance
was translated into the approval of the first RNA interference
(RNAi)-based drug, Patisiran (Onpattro), for the treatment of
hereditary transthyretin-mediated amyloidosis (hATTR).
5–7)
Patisiran is a lipid-based formulation encapsulating siRNA
and efficiently targets liver hepatocytes after intravenous
administration to cause efficient and durable silencing of the
abnormal form of the transthyretin gene. This breakthrough in
the field of nonviral gene delivery received substantial interest
worldwide and clearly showed the importance of lipid-based
systems for developing more approved drugs in the future.
Several synthetic vectors are available for gene delivery.
One strategy depends on using conjugates of different nucleic
acids with different functional devices such as peptides,
polymers, sugars, proteins, antibodies, or aptamers.
8,9)
An-
other strategy depends on encapsulating the nucleic acids in
nanoparticles (NPs) of appropriate size. Conjugate systems
are small in size and can easily be eliminated from the body
through glomerular filtration in the kidney.
10)
Furthermore,
the nucleic acids in the conjugates are not protected and must
be chemically modified to resist degradation with nucleases
in the circulation. NP systems, on the other hand, are large
enough to bypass kidney elimination and can provide more
protection of nucleic acids in the circulation. The NPs used
for gene delivery can be broadly classified into polymeric
and lipid nanoparticles (LNPs). The latter provide several ad-
vantages including higher stability, low toxicity, and greater
efficiency.
11–14)
In addition, systems based on LNPs can be
easily modified with other ligands and devices for controlled
biodistribution and internalization into specific cells.
To increase the efficiency and decrease the side effects of
lipid-based gene vectors, the systems must avoid rapid clear-
ance and inactivation in the serum and must have the ability
* To whom correspondence should be addressed. e-mail: harasima@pharm.hokudai.ac.jp
Current Topics
Recent Advances in Research on Particulate Formulations such as Lipoproteins,
Liposomes, Extracellular Vesicles, and iPS-Derived Cells
Review