Universal Journal of Educational Research 8(8): 3360-3370, 2020 http://www.hrpub.org
DOI: 10.13189/ujer.2020.080808
Factors Affecting ESL Students' Willingness to
Communicate in English Classroom Discussions
and Their Use of Linguistic Strategies
Maryam Jahedi, Lilliati Ismail
*
Department of Language and Humanities Education, Faculty of Educational Studies, Universiti Putra Malaysia, Malaysia
Received March 29, 2020; Revised May 20, 2020; Accepted May 27, 2020
Copyright ©2020 by authors, all rights reserved. Authors agree that this article remains permanently open access under
the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0 International License
Abstract In the past few years, the importance of
willingness to communicate (WTC) has received greater
attention among scholars in the field as it has generally
been found that WTC is closely related to the development
of linguistic competence. This study employed the WTC
Model (MacIntyre et al., 1998) and Halliday’s (1985)
Systemic Functional Linguistics to examine Malaysian
students’ WTC behavior through the analysis of classroom
observations, journal entries and interview data. Thematic
analysis was used to identify the situational factors
affecting students’ WTC in classroom discussion
interactions. Moreover, linguistic analysis of the data
concentrated on interpersonal meaning of tenor to find out
how students’ WTC was realized and how role relations
were established among them through mood patterns and
speech functions. The study found the major factors that
increased the students’ WTC in the classroom discussions
including topics of interest, relevance of the topic to one’s
experience, teaching method, the relationship with peers,
etc. Furthermore, the findings revealed that the students’
WTC was realized linguistically through the predominant
use of declarative and interrogative discourse. Moreover,
students tended to react more through supporting moves
rather than confronting moves which showed a cooperative
and positive atmosphere in the classroom. It can be
concluded that students’ WTC in a particular situation is
related to certain factors that promote their behavioral
WTC to be manifested through language.
Keywords L2 Learners, Situational Factors of WTC,
Speech Functions, Systemic Functional Linguistics,
Willingness to Communicate
1. Introduction
Over the past few years, the importance of willingness to
communicate (WTC) in the second language (L2) has been
given particular importance and studies have tried to find
ways to promote learners’ WTC, especially in classroom
interactions. WTC is “conceptualized as a readiness to
speak in the L2 at a particular time with a specific person,
and as such, is the final psychological step to the initiation
of L2 communication” (MacIntyre & Doucette, 2010, p.
162). Learners who do not participate in the second
language interaction are considered passive and
unmotivated (Cao, 2009). Therefore, there is a concern for
the students who are unwilling to communicate in the L2
(MacIntyre, & Doucett, 2010) since lack of English
proficiency can put them at a disadvantage in the job
market (Nair et al., 2012). In order for students to reach the
desired level of English proficiency, there is a need to
encourage them to communicate more in the English
language (Yousef, Jamil & Razak, 2013).
As WTC is related to language teaching and learning, it
is important to examine it in ESL or EFL classroom-based
contexts (Abd Rahman, Abd Samad & Abu Bakar, 2020;
Cao, 2009; Riasati & Noordin, 2011; Manipuspika, 2018;
Riasati, 2018). Studies on WTC “centered mainly on the
use of structural models and trait, self-reported
measurements of WTC, but recent research has shown that
WTC is also heavily dependent on the situation” (Robson,
2015, iii); yet, situational variables have not been
addressed adequately (Yashima, MacIntyre & Ikeda, 2018).
Moreover, WTC as a construct is treated more as “a
measure of whether someone will initiate talk rather than
how much the person actually speaks” (Dörnyei & Kormos,
2000, p. 286). Although the use of certain linguistic means
and strategies contribute to students’ WTC in the English
language classroom which can increase their English
proficiency level (Nakatani, 2006), research on WTC from
the linguistic point of view is scarce. Understanding the
linguistic choices made by students to manifest their WTC
can help English learners to “utilize their existing