Universal Journal of Educational Research 7(10): 2115-2123, 2019 http://www.hrpub.org
DOI: 10.13189/ujer.2019.071009
NL Switching as a Compensatory Strategy of Indonesian
EFL School Students and Its Pedagogical Implication
Endang Fauziati
*
, Abdillah Nugroho, Susiati, Muhamad Taufik Hidayat
Universitas Muhammadiyah Surakarta, Indonesia
Received July 30, 2019; Revised September 16, 2019; Accepted September 23, 2019
Copyright©2019 by authors, all rights reserved. Authors agree that this article remains permanently open access under
the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0 International License
Abstract This study aimed to provide an empirical
evidence of NL Switching as compensatory strategy of
EFL school students in their written communication. The
focus was to identify, describe, and explain the linguistic
realization and patterns of the NL switching to compensate
for their missing language knowledge and proposing its
pedagogical implication. The data were in the form of
words, phrases, and sentences reflecting NL switching as
compensatory strategy, which were elicited from the
students’ English free composition and results from
interview. The data were identified, described, and
explained based on relevant perspectives. The results
indicated that the lexical switching as compensatory
strategy in communication was in the form of Indonesian
naturalized borrowed words from Arabic, Indonesian
words, Indonesian cognate, and Indonesian abbreviation,
while the syntactical switching was in the form of
Indonesian collocation, Indonesian construction, and
Indonesian conjunction. The findings of this study provide
empirical evidence on NL switching in Indonesian EFL
school students' written communication.
Keywords Lexical & Syntactical Strategy, NL
Switching, Compensatory Strategy, Cultural-loaded Words
1. Introduction
EFL classroom is commonly the only place where
learners are engaged in communication using English.
Sometimes, however, while speaking and writing, they
face some difficulties to keep the flow of communication.
To overcome this problem they use code switching as
compensation strategy. Compensation or compensatory
strategy comes under the broader term communication
strategies or strategic competence, the strategies employed
by creative learners to circumvent their linguistic
difficulties or inadequacies in the second language (L2).
Dornyei (1997) stated that this term first raised as
researchers noticed the mismatch between EFL learners'
linguistic resources and communicative intentions which
led to language phenomenon whose main function was to
cope with problems in L2 communication. He presented
taxonomy of communication strategies, consisting of two
kinds which reveal two opposite directions in
communication, avoiding and compensating. Through
avoiding, learners try to avoid topic areas that pose
language problems and through compensating, they find
ways to compensate for the difficulties.
That is to say, compensatory strategies are the ones used
by EFL learners in production of the language they are
learning. The strategies are made up for compensating an
insufficient repertoire of vocabulary and grammar (Oxford,
2003). When facing with problems in expressing their
ideas in the target language, EFL learners may find a
solution, such as making use of various cognitive
compensatory strategies to directly handle the problems.
The purpose of the use of compensatory strategies is to
make up for an inadequate repertoire of vocabulary and
grammar. For this end, EFL learners commonly find
solution from their native language (NL), that is, by code
switching to their NL in terms of grammar and vocabulary.
These strategies are commonly activated when they want to
achieve the oral and written communication goal but
having insufficient linguistic resources (Olivares &
Fonseca, 2013). Oxford (2003) states that compensation
strategies enable learners to use the target language for
comprehension and production despite their limitations in
the knowledge. Compensation strategies are used to make
up for an inadequate repertoire of lexical and grammatical
knowledge. Oxford (2003) identifies compensatory
strategy as one of six major groups of L2 learning
strategies, i.e. cognitive strategies, metacognitive strategies,
memory-related strategies, compensatory strategies,
affective strategies, social strategies. She (2003) divides
compensatory strategy into guessing intelligently and
overcoming limitations in speaking and writing. And
strategy to overcome limitations consists of eight strategies
CITE THIS PAPER
[1] Endang Fauziati , Abdillah Nugroho , Susiati , Muhamad Taufik Hidayat , "NL Switching as a Compensatory Strategy of
Indonesian EFL School Students and Its Pedagogical Implication," Universal Journal of Educational Research, Vol. 7, No. 10, pp.
2115 - 2123, 2019. DOI: 10.13189/ujer.2019.071009.